This study was undertaken to clarify the etiology of Binswanger's disease based on the relationships between vascular lesions and white-matter changes characterizing the disease. We focussed on the extracranial carotid artery and peripheral artery of the lower limbs in Binswanger's disease, and evaluated the carotid ultrasonographic findings and the ankle pressure index (API) as compared to those in control groups. The mean age of our 21 patients with Binswanger's disease (Binswanger group) was 79.9 years (5 males and 16 females). The diagnosis was made from the clinical features and computed tomography (CT) findings, which showed diffuse low-density areas of white matter in the bilateral hemispheres, compatible with the clinical criteria of Binswanger's disease as proposed by Bennett et al. The controls consisted of 3 groups : 67 patients with lacunar infarction (perforating group), 52 patients with cortical infarction (cortical group), and 70 individuals without cerebrovascular disease examined on CT (non-CVD group). Patients with atrial fibrillation were excluded from the study. The extracranial carotidlesions, examined by 7.5-MHz B-mode ultrasonography, included occlusions and plaques. Plaque was defined as a thickened intima-media complex of 2.1 mm or more, and was divided into two types according to the ratio of the plaque length to thickness : nodular plaques (< 3) and mural plaques (≥ 3). Intravenous digital subtraction angiography was also performed in some patients. Moreover, the API, expressed as the ratio of the ankle pressure to brachial pressure determined by 5-MHz Doppler ultrasound, was studied and a low API (<0.9) was considered to indicate obstructive changes in the legs. In the Binswanger group, carotid lesions were frequently observed in 16 patients, who included 2 patients with carotid occlusion and 16 patients with plaque alone. In particular, the incidence of bilateral carotid lesions was 71% in the Binswanger group, which was significantly higher than that in the perforating (28%), cortical (44%), and non-CVD (23%) groups. Most of the lesions comprised nodular plaques as observed in half of the carotid arteries, although the plaques in the Binswanger group were thinner than those in the cortical group. A low API, seen in 43% of the Binswanger group, tended to be frequent, when compared to that in the non-CVD group.
In conclusion, a high incidence of atherosclerotic lesions in both the extracranial carotid artery and peripheral artery of the lower limbs in Binswanger's disease indicated that severe athero- and arteriosclerosis had already developed in this disease. Although in a few cases the carotid lesions could have contributed to the white-matter changes, plaques were considered to frequently accompany arteriolar changes in the white matter, which proved difficult to detect clinically. The causes of the white-matter changes, were therefore small-vessel disease, with or without large-vessel disease, but the carotid lesions could have promoted the small-vessel damage and the white-matter changes in some manner (decreased “Windkessel” function).
View full abstract