We surveyed the occurrence risk of needle rust caused by Coleosporium phellodendri and Asian pine gall rust caused by Cronartium orientale on Japanese black pine (Pinus thunbergii) cultivated at bonsai production areas in Takamatsu City, Kagawa Prefecture, in 2016. Our results suggested that the risk of damage due to needle rust would be very low given that Phellodendron amurense, the alternate host, was not found within 300m from the bonsai garden where bonsai trees for export are cultivated. However, we found alternate hosts of Asian pine gall rust within 300m of the gardens. Nonetheless, based on the fact that a roughly 100-year-old Japanese black pine showed no symptoms of Asian pine gall rust, it is likely that the disease had not occurred for at least 100 years, or if it had, proper management had resulted in complete elimination from the gardens. Considering multiple factors, including the life cycles of the two pathogenic fungi, bonsai cultivation and management methods, disease control, and weather conditions, together with the results of the present survey, it is highly unlikely that damage due to these two diseases would occur in the future as well. With regard to the importation of bonsai of Japanese black pine into Europe, which is wary about the invasion of pathogenic fungi that cause needle rust and Asian pine gall rust of Japanese black pine, the risk of their invasion into European countries would be extremely low by taking the same quarantine measures as those implemented for bonsai of Japanese white pine (Pinus parviflora), which have already been exported.
View full abstract