A 68 year-old right handed woman lived in Singapore for 17 years from the age of 9, and spoke Japanese with her family, and English at school. She was working at a trading company after her return to Japan at the age of 26. She usually spoke Japanese but her English was also fluent. She has been teaching English to high-school students since she retired from her company.
In May 1988. the patient was admitted to our hospital because of the abrupt onset of speech loss. First, she was able to speak nothing but showed good understanding. As she recovered, her English speaking ability was always better than her Japanese. In the standard language test of aphasia, she showed good results with easy problems but as the complexity of the problems increased, her results worsened.
Further investigations have been reported in Europe and America for polyglot aphasia. Three main recovery rules of polyglot aphasia have been reported. First, Ribot's theory that native language recovers fastest, second, Pitre's theory that familial factor is the most important and third, Minkowsky's theory that language recovers when emotional factors are present. In our case the progress of the recovery process was different compared with these rules of recovery of a polyglot aphasia in Europe and America, as her English recovered faster than her native language, and no familial or emotional factors were present.
This result shows the possibility of a fundamental difference in the recovery process between Japanese aphasia and aphasia in Europe and America.
View full abstract