Pure anarthria is known to occur after a lesion of the inferior precentral gyrus. However, anarthria caused by a localized lesion is often transient, suggesting a compensatory mechanism by the contralateral homologous cortical area.
A right-handed 60-year-old male who suddenly became mute on the job came to our hospital. Neurological examination revealed severe anarthria and mild right facial weakness. Mild dysgraphia was initially noted but improved in three months. Severe anarthria associated with dysprosody persisted. Magnetic resonance imaging of the brain revealed bilateral cerebral infarctions : a left-side lesion extending from the inferior to the medial portion of the precentral gyrus, and a right-side lesion extending from the inferior precentral gyrus to the foot of the middle frontal gyrus and to the opercular portion of the inferior frontal gyrus. Repeated X-ray computed tomographies revealed that the right hemispheric lesion was older than the left hemispheric one.
From studies of anarthric cases with bilateral frontal lesions, two hypotheses have hitherto been proposed as to the compensatory mechanism for articulatory disturbances : Nielsen (1946) suggested that the role of the right hemispheric area is homologous with the Broca's area, while Levine et al. (1979) stressed the importance of the left hemispheric residual region around the Broca's area.
The clinical findings of the present case do not support the hypothesis of Levine et al. because severe anarthria persisted despite a well-circumscribed lesion in the left inferior precentral gyrus. On the other hand, Nielsen's theory perhaps explains the persistence of anarthria ; i. e., the lesion in the right inferior precentral gyrus is thought to interrupt the compensatory mechanism of the right hemisphere.
View full abstract