In order to elucidate the nature of processing deficits underlying production of paraphasias in aphasic patients, and to reconsider the implication of them in the aphasic symptomatology, three lines of discussion were presented.
1) Some authors claimed that the frequency of production of paraphasias is not different between types of aphasic syndromes. These opinions were predominantly based upon the results of naming tasks. We insisted that frequent occurrence of paraphasias in running speech, not in naming task, would be in general the characteristic of posterior aphasia with fluent speech.
2) We presented some unusual cases with posterior aphasia, three with Wernicke's aphasia and one with transcortical sensory aphasia. Although their speech was fluent with normal articulation and syntax, we could not find out any contamination with paraphasias in it. It consisted of demonstrative pronouns, conventional phrases, mimetic words, and function words, all of which conveying no definite information. We proposed to designate the feature of their speech “no content word jargon”.
All of the four cases with no content word jargon had widespread damage involving anterior and posterior portion of the left temporal lobe, in addition to the lesions in posterior temporal and parietal region. Anterior and inferior portion of left temporal lobe might play an important role in promoting the retrieval of content words.
Paraphasias observed in usual cases with posterior aphasia would be a sign to demonstrate that both of word representation and promoting mechanism of word retrieval are spared in such cases.
3) A case of deep dysphasia was reported. Her speech was a typical neologistic jargon in the acute stage of her disease. Ten months after onset, we noticed that she made abundant semantic paraphasias as well as neologisms in a single word repetition. She had recovered the ability to comprehend single words, and she was able to retrieve a lot of appropriate content words in free conversation.
On the analysis of her responses in repetition tasks, we concluded that the occurrence of semantic paraphasia in a single word repetition could not be attributed to STM deficit. Instead, we proposed the hypothesis that there are two separate routes in spoken word production. Word production by the route bypassing the Wernicke's area would be relevant to the occurrence of semantic paraphasias.
View full abstract