Since the early 2000s, universities have been increasingly expected to offer students learning opportunities that promote the acquisition of fundamental competencies required for professional and civic life. In response, the adoption of active learning pedagogies that incorporate group-based activities has become widespread across higher education. The objective of these approaches is to cultivate not only knowledge but also critical skills such as communication, collaboration, and problem-solving. However, despite these intentions, a number of studies have reported negative outcomes, which highlight persistent challenges in the effective implementation of group learning effectively. One factor that may contribute to these difficulties is student’s psychological resistance or apprehension, particularly at the initial stages of collaborative work. The current study investigates the extent to which instructional efforts to establish a supportive and inclusive learning environment can address these concerns. Specifically, it examines the effects of instructors’ deliberate strategies (e.g., fostering a positive classroom atmosphere, designing introductory activities to ease students into collaboration, and providing timely interventions) on students’ perceptions and attitudes toward group learning. The results indicate decreases in mean scores on a concern measurement scale when instructors proactively engaged in creating the abovementioned environment, which indicates a reduction in students’ initial resistance. Moreover, the results of correspondence analysis revealed that instructors’ early instructional strategies, demeanor, and nature of interventions were significantly associated with this outcome. The findings also underscored that environmental structure alone was insufficient for addressing all student concerns, which indicates the need for multifaceted approaches. This study contributes to an in-depth understanding of the psychological dynamics of group learning and provides practical insights for educators in designing effective active learning environments.
View full abstract