Experiments were done to determine the generation time of M. ulcerans (PD) on 3 types of media, Ogawa's 1% KH
2PO
4 medium, the Kirchner agar and the Dubos medium. The method of determination of generation time was that given by Youmans and Youmans.(3)
The generation time of M. ulcerans (PD) was calculated as being about 42 hours at 33°C and 56 hours at 37°C by the method described above. The generation time of M. tuberculosis (H
37Rv) was about 36 hours at 33°C and about 25 hours at 37°C and that of M. muris (Wells) was about 44 hours at 33°C and 33 hours at 37°C.
These experiments showed that the growth rate of M. ulcerans was stimulated at 33°C, whereas that of M. tuberculosis was stimulated at 37°C. The growth rate of M. muris at 33°C resembled that of M. ulcerans, but the growth was stimulated at 37°C.
In the experiments mentioned above, the generation time of H
37Rv at 37°C was about 25 hours, and Holmgren and Youmans
(4) calculated the generation time of this strain as 23.08±1.36 hours in the Proskauer and Beck medium at 37°C.
We obtained a value essentially similar to that described by Holmgren et al. and Gutiérrez-Vázquez.
(5)According to the experiments of Leach and Fenner,
(6) the generation time of M. ulcerans (SF) was below 48 hours in the Dubos medium at 33°C, and our data on M. ulcerans (PD) showed 44 hours in the Dubos medium without serum. The discrepancy may first be due to the strain, secondly to the calculation method.
The results of our experiments at 37°C suggest that the growth rates of M. tuberculosis and M, muris are similar but that of M. ulcerans is half of M. tuberculosis. In the case of 33°C there is an agreement between the growth rates of M. ulcerans and M. muris, but M. tuberculosis showed different data.
Observations made on the correlation between catalase activity and rate of growth revealed that M. tuberculosis shows a slow growth rate and moderate catalase activity, but, in general, avirulent mycobacteria contain a large amount of catalase and their generation rate is high. The catalase activities of M. ulcerans and M. muris are stronger than that of M. tuberculosis, but the growth rate of M. ulcerans is lower than that of M. tuberculosis.
View full abstract