In 1873, the second year after the start of the modern elementary school system (
gakusei) in Japan, the Ministry of Education published several textbooks, among which
Chiri-Shoho was one. It was believed that the original text of
Chiri-Shoho was Cornell's geography textbooks that had been used widely in the USA.
There have been two views of the original text held by different scholars. One argued that
Cornell's Primary Geography was used as the source book and
Cornell's High-School Geography was referred to for supplements. The other contended that
Cornell's First Steps in Geography was the original text. Neither of those views was based on minute verification.
This paper aims to ascertain the original text of
Chiri-Shoho. There were six Cornell geography textbooks in print when
Chiri-Shoho was published. In addition to the three mentioned above, they were
Cornell's Intermediate Geography, Cornell's Grammar-School Geography and Cornell's Physical Geography. All six books are candidates for the original text. This paper compares the text of
Chiri-Shoho to the six Cornell geography textbooks sentence by sentence and illustration by illustration.
As a result, the author concludes that the original text of
Chiri-Shoho was
Cornell's Primary Geography, written for elementary school students. However, there are several sentences and illustrations in
Chiri-Shoho not found in
Cornell's Primary Geography. Those are mostly from
Cornell's First Steps in Geography, Cornell's Intermediate Geography, and
Cornell's Grammar-School Geography.
Cornell's First Steps in Geography is an introductory textbook and precedes
Cornell's Primary Geography. Chiri-Shoho uses it for easier or supplementary explanations.
Cornell's Intermediate Geography and
Cornell's Grammar-School Geography are textbooks for students who completed
Cornell's Primary Geography.
Chiri-Shoho adopts some topics from these two textbooks which
Cornell's Primary Geography does not teach.
A few sentences and illustrations in
Chiri-Shoho cannot be found in any of the Cornell geography textbooks. Interestingly, those are all related to shipping and navigation. Also
Chiri-Shoho changes or rewrites some contents of the Cornell geography textbooks based on the Japanese context.
View full abstract