The aim of the present study is to compare how towels made of different materials (cotton and synthetic material) influence the effects of bed baths. The subjects comprised 16 healthy women, who underwent partial bed baths of their back, legs and arms with the same method on different days using different types of towels on each day. Towels made of cotton and synthetic materials were used, and all towels were 47×17 cm in size. Each towel was soaked in 200 mL of water and heated to 55.0±0.2℃. The bed bath effects for each type of towel were compared after being evaluated using the multidimensional indices of skin temperature, deep temperature, blood pressure, heart rate (HR), short form of the profile of mood states (POMS-SF), wakening and relaxing visual analogue scale (VAS) and a Likert scale for the texture of each type of material. Results indicated that for both cotton and synthetic towels, the subjects’ HR temporarily decreased during the bed bath and after the bed bath was completed, significant decreases in POMS score, and reductions in wakening and increases in relaxation were observed (
P <0.05). Bed baths did not lead to any marked changes in autonomic nervous activity but during bed baths with cotton towels only, sympathetic nervous activity (LF/HF) decreased significantly (
P <0.05). For both types of towels, skin temperature in the precordial area and forearms, and deep body temperature rose for a short time after starting the bed bath (
P <0.05). With the synthetic towels, skin temperature in the peripheries (forearms, right fingertips) also rose (
P <0.05). With regards to texture after completion of the bed bath, the synthetic towels were evaluated as having a more appropriate level of softness (
P <0.05). The above results suggest that although both synthetic and cotton towels offer good partial bed bath effects that are almost identical, synthetic towels offer superior warmth and texture.
View full abstract