Purpose: In the 2016 dental fee revision, prosthetic crown shade selection tests, denture chewing function tests, and tongue pressure tests became covered by national health insurance. The purpose of this study was to clarify the implementation status of these tests in the clinical setting and to study the extent of their implementation compared with the estimates given in the Health Technology Assessment Proposal at the time of their introduction.
Method: The number of implementations of these tests in medical practice (subtypes) was investigated in the Ministry of Health, Labour, and Welfare’s Social Medical Practices Survey conducted in 2016, 2017, and 2018. The proportion of prosthetic crown shade selection tests performed during cementation of metal crowns with resin-facing and hard resin jacket crowns, the proportion of denture chewing function tests performed during insertion of removable partial dentures (multi edentulous) and complete dentures, and the proportion of tongue pressure tests performed during insertion of palatal augmentation prostheses for the purpose of improving contact function were compared. A comparative study of these tests against the estimates in the Health Technology Assessment Proposal was performed.
Results: The crown prosthetic shade selection test was performed in approximately 5% of applicable cases, which was approximately 7% of the estimated number. Almost no denture chewing function tests were performed in 2016, and their number increased slightly to 0.2% in 2017 and to 0.4% in 2018. Beginning in 2016, multiple calculations of tongue pressure tests were performed in necessary cases. The proportion of tests was 12%–13% of the estimated number. From 2018, their applicability expanded, and there was a large increase in implementation.
Discussion and conclusions: The actual numbers of all the tests were far below those estimated in the Health Technology Assessment Proposal. This finding suggests that with respect to new medical technology proposals, in addition to monitoring the change over time, it is necessary to pay attention to the implementation estimates in the future.
View full abstract