Civic republicanism, which dates to Aristotle, and social contract theory are two concepts that have informed discourse surrounding freedom, citizenship and politics in liberal democracies. Both, however, have been substantially dependent on the exclusion of several groups, to the extent that citizenship used to take a form that disenfranchised slaves, women, and imperial subjects. The legacy of that may be discerned in the modern nation-state system, with the uneven distribution, for example, of citizenship benefits across various gradations, from "full" to "second-class" citizenship. While universal equality is an ideal by-product of official citizenship, the experiential realities of citizenship vary according to regional and historical contexts.
The material examined in this paper was obtained from field research conducted in a pastoral society composed of so-called second-class citizens who have been denied agency by the linear modernization theory of the nation-state from the colonial era to the postcolonial period. Against the backdrop of the decentralization of state power following globalization, the gaze of the West was directed toward the periphery of Uganda, Kenya and South Sudan, and forced disarmament and sedentary development policy that were heavily promoted in cooperation with the central government. Under such circumstances, how have the pastoral Dodoth in the Karamoja region of Uganda resisted the suppressive policy of the government against nomadism and the practices of ethnic citizenship? The Ugandan government, which has adopted a policy opposed to subsistence-pastoralism in pursuit of a national isomorphism of politics, economics, culture and society, has regularly raided the livestock of pastoralists living in the Karamoja area, making it impossible for the ethnic community to claim citizenship. The analytic focus of this paper, therefore, is on the way in which those pastoralists have embodied the practice of ethnic citizenship in defense of their habitat and as a means of resisting the dominant order, bypassing the normative idea of citizenship.
(View PDF for the rest of the abstract.)
View full abstract