Oral diadochokinesis is one of the oral functional indices. The following three methods are used to evaluate it : the
IC method, in which the experimenter measures the recorded sound wave on a recorder ; the
calculator method, in which the experimenter taps the memory function key of a calculator, synchronized with the syllables ; and the
dot method, in which the experimenter dots with a pen, synchronized with the syllables. Recently, we developed a new measurement device, KENKOU-KUN, which automatically measures oral diadochokinesis. The purpose of this study was to compare the accuracy of oral diadochokinesis measurement by the IC-method, the calculator-method, and the KENKOU-KUN method.
Forty nine 79-year-old people (26 men, 23 women) participated in a cohort study conducted in 2007, and 355 elderly people (175 men, 180 women) participated in the 2008 study. They were instructed to repeat the syllables /pa/, /ta/, and /ka/ as well as possible for five seconds. The oral diadochokinesis was measured with the IC-method, the calculator-method, and the KENKOU-KUN method.
The average numbers of /pa/, /ta/, and /ka/ were 6.0±0.9, 6.0±0.9, and 5.7±0.8/sec, respectively. There was a strong positive correlation between the IC method and the KENKOU-KUN method (p<0.01) . On the other hand, the correlation between the IC method and the calculator method was weaker than that between the IC method and the KENKOU-KUN method. The number of miscounts with the calculator-method increased in cases over 7.0/s with the IC-method. This might relate the slower speed of finger tapping compared to oral diadochokinesis.
It was shown that the KENKOU-KUN method could precisely measure the oral diadochokinesis, while the calculator method was less accurate. Further studies are required to establish criteria by age and the degree of care needed.
View full abstract