In this study, we extracted naive conceptions about electrical resistance from the “electrical and magnetic” unit in high school physics, examined the relevant existing teaching materials and instructional programs, developed a new lesson plan to foster pupils’ correction of the prior naive conception, and put it into practice in the classroom. First, from a conceptual survey on the shape and resistance value of electrical resistance, many students said such things as “The larger the volume of electrical resistance, the larger the resistance value”, and “The resistance value increases as the length of electrical resistance becomes longer. And it does not depend on the cross-sectional area”. In this research, in order to correct these naive conceptions and to form a scientific concept, we created a type of clay which is conductive and whose resistivity and shape can be freely changed, and we used this in the experiment. Through experiments, the students clarified the contradiction between naive conceptions and scientific concepts. In addition, through group discussions after the experiment, students clarified the factors behind the acquisition of naive conceptions and considered ways to explain scientific concepts. Through these processes, naive conceptions related to electrical resistance were corrected and scientific concepts were formed. From the results of pre-, post-, and delayed surveys, it was confirmed that through the devised instruction programs using conductive clay, the students’ naive conceptions about electrical resistance were corrected, the scientific concept was formed, and, indeed, the formed scientific concept could be successfully maintained.
View full abstract