The authors demonstrated three examples of collision of two balls to fourth, fifth and sixth graders at elementary school. Children were then asked to write down their conception of the collisions. At least one of the examples was so selected as to be inconsistent with their preconception about collision. On the basis of the children’s description, we classified their conceptual changes into eight types, including “Creation,” “Replacement,” “Extension,” “Modification,” “Unification,” “Persistency,” “Decrease” and “No Reason,” The findings from this project were as follows: (1) Five of the conceptual change types i.e., “Creation,” “Replacement,” “Extension,” “Modification” and “Unification,”, which can be regarded as giving “positive educational effects” account for about 70% of the descriptions. Accordingly, we claim the children can study aggressively by themselves. (2) The higher graders the children become the more based on their preconception they study. (3) The sequence of the children’s conceptual change through counterexample demonstration is: “Creation” → “Persistency” → “Replacement” → “Extension” and “Modification” → “Unification.” This sequence seems to reflect the process of children’s conception formation. However, some children seem to have “ad-hoc” conceptions or “firm” preconceptions. Therefore, further studies on emotional and meta-cognitive aspect would be required for confirming the above findings.
View full abstract