We reviewed the clinical results of patients treated for subarachnoid hemorrhages (SAH) between 1996 and 2000 at the Emergency Department and Critical Care Unit of Tama-Nagayama Hospital, Nippon Medical School. One-hundred and fifteen consecutive cases of SAH between January 1996 and December 2000 (latter group) were studied, and the results were compared with those of 124 SAH cases treated between January 1991 and December 1995 (former group). Neurological grades were classified according to the World Federation of Neurological Surgeons (WFNS) grading scale, and the outcome of SAH was determined using the Glasgow Outcome Scale (GOS). Coil embolization and induced mild hypothermia therapy were performed as additional treatments in the latter group. The WFNS grades of the former group were I (8 cases), I (13 cases), III (6 cases), IV (41 cases) and V (55 cases), while those of the latter group were I (6 cases), II (21 cases), III (4 cases), IV (34 cases) and V (50 cases). The number of cases that experienced radical obliteration of the ruptured aneurysms were 6 (I), 9 (II), 3 (III), 22 (IV) and 10 (V) in the former group and 5 (I), 20 (III), 3 (III), 33 (IV) and 22 (V) in the latter group. The outcomes of the SAH in the former group were a good recovery (GR) in 22 cases, moderate disability (MD) in 8 cases, severe disability (SD) in 13 cases, persistent vegetative state (PVS) in 6 cases, and death (D) in 75 cases. On the other hand, the outcomes of SAH in the latter group were GR in 42 cases, MD in 12 cases, SD in 9 cases, PVS in 9 cases, and D in 43 cases. Regarding the overall outcome of SAH cases in the two groups, the latter group fared better than the former group (p<0.01). The improvement in the latter group was due to the higher rate of surgical intervention in cases with a WFNS grade of IV or V. In addition, the frequency of deterioration in cases with WFNS grades of I, II or III was smaller in the latter group (2 out of 31 cases) compared to the former group (9 out of 27 cases). When only the surgically treated cases were compared, the differences in outcome were not statistically significant. We conclude that an early estimation of the severity grade, preoperative deep sedation, and radical treatment, even in severe cases (with the exception of completely contraindicated cases, such as those with a loss of brain stem reaction) may prevent death and improve the outcome of SAH.
View full abstract