Objectives: In Japan, legislations for terminal care have not been fully developed, and various terminal-care guidelines have been presented by various institutions. However, these guidelines are markedly vague, and their contents are insufficient. During resuscitation procedures for out-of-hospital cardiopulmonary arrests, it is sometimes possible to confirm a clear living will for “do-not-attempt-resuscitation” (DNAR) at the end of life. Currently, however, there are no well-defined criteria regarding the appropriate timing for considering treatment discontinuation or abstention; resuscitation is often followed by intensive care. We aimed to determine the current situation and problematic issues related to DNAR in out-of-hospital cardiopulmonary arrest patients.
Subjects and Methods: A retrospective study was conducted on the basis of the medical records of out-of-hospital cardiopulmonary arrest patients who were transported to St. Luke's International Hospital's Emergency and Critical Care Center between April 2009 and March 2010.
Results: The presence or absence of a living will for DNAR was confirmed in 126 of the 304 patients studied. Twenty-nine (23.0%) patients had left a living will for DNAR, but 8 of these patients (approximately one-fourth) showed a return of spontaneous circulation (ROSC) and ended up receiving resuscitation treatment and intensive care against their will. One patient was discharged from the hospital without any neurological sequelae and with cerebral performance category 1 (CPC1), whereas another patient, who was stabilized in a vegetative state after overcoming the acute phase, was transferred to another hospital with CPC4.
Conclusion: With the current insufficiency of laws and guidelines regarding end-of-life care, cardiopulmonary arrest patients with a living will for DNAR at the end of life are still likely to receive treatment. Receiving unwanted treatment may result in the patient's survival with a loss of dignity. To avoid such an unfortunate situation, accurate prognostic methods for patients with cardiopulmonary arrest are desired, and the entire nation needs to consider whether cardiopulmonary arrest itself should be conceived of as the end of life. On the basis of the consensus from this debate, laws and guidelines pertaining to terminal care should be developed as soon as possible.
View full abstract