Nihon Koshu Eisei Zasshi(JAPANESE JOURNAL OF PUBLIC HEALTH)
Online ISSN : 2187-8986
Print ISSN : 0546-1766
ISSN-L : 0546-1766
Volume 69, Issue 5
Displaying 1-6 of 6 articles from this issue
Review article
  • Tsuguhiko KATO, Manami OCHI, Yuko KACHI, Maiko SUTO, Miyako OTSUKA, Ke ...
    2022 Volume 69 Issue 5 Pages 321-337
    Published: May 15, 2022
    Released on J-STAGE: May 24, 2022
    Advance online publication: March 16, 2022
    JOURNAL FREE ACCESS

    Objectives Recently, paternal involvement in childcare has been gaining public attention in Japan. However, studies on the influences of active paternal involvement remain scarce. This study aimed to review the findings on the influence of paternal involvement in childcare on mothers, children, and fathers themselves from studies conducted in Japan and published mainly after 2010. Additionally, we examined methodological issues that need to be addressed when researchers conduct studies on paternal involvement in the future.

    Methods We reviewed 26 journal articles (22 in Japanese and 4 in English) from four databases: “Igaku Chuo Zasshi Web (Japana Centra Revuo Medicina History and Activities),” JSTPlus, JMEDPlus, and PubMed with conditions such as studies conducted in Japan, families with young children, and questionnaire-based quantitative studies. We described respondents (mothers, fathers, or both) and assessed paternal involvement in childcare, outcomes, and findings.

    Results We reviewed studies on paternal involvement in childcare published in Japanese after 2010 and English after 2000 and observed two trends across the studies. The first was that if mothers acknowledge active paternal involvement in childcare, mothers’ parenting stress seemed to be lower, and they seemed to be happier. Moreover, for children's health and development, active paternal involvement seemed to be associated with positive results, such as prevention of unintentional injuries and obesity. However, in the second trend, we observed that active paternal involvement, assessed by the fathers themselves, were often not associated with lower parenting stress among mothers. We also could not observe a consistent trend on the findings related to the influences on fathers, due to the limited number of studies. We observed that assessment of paternal involvement in childcare was inconsistent across studies included in this review.

    Conclusion With more social pressure for fathers to be actively involved in childcare, public interest for the influence would be heightened. For future studies, better ways of assessing the quantity and content of paternal involvement in childcare need to be discussed.

    Download PDF (429K)
  • Marisa NISHIO, Maho HASEDA, Mariko KANAMORI, Yuki ARAKAWA, Naoki KONDO
    2022 Volume 69 Issue 5 Pages 338-356
    Published: May 15, 2022
    Released on J-STAGE: May 24, 2022
    Advance online publication: March 16, 2022
    JOURNAL FREE ACCESS

    Objectives The Commission on Social Determinants of Health (CSDH) of the World Health Organization (WHO) recommends that national and municipal governments take adequate steps to “improve daily living conditions,” “(create governance to) tackle the inequitable distribution of power, money, and resources,” and “measure and understand the problem and assess the impact of” government actions. This study provides an analysis of the health promotion policies of Japan and other countries and examines their conformance to these recommendations, and offers suggestions for developing a conducive social environment for Japan's health promotion policies.

    Methods We reviewed grey literature on health promotion policies in Japan, the USA, England, Sweden, and Thailand, extracting the definitions of health inequalities and their characterization in each policy, and analyzing each document vis-á-vis the CSDH's three recommendations and “comprehensive national health equity surveillance framework.”

    Results The health promotion policies of Japan, England, Sweden, and the USA had similar definitions of health inequality, emphasizing fairness and prioritizing the reduction of health inequality as the key strategy for health promotion. However, their primary approaches to improve daily living conditions varied: In Japan, the primary approach is to create opportunities for participation and ensure access to social resources. Meanwhile, the USA relies largely on objective assessments and scientific evidence-based actions. England focused on enhancing support for socially disadvantaged individuals and areas. In Sweden, a universal intervention based on life-course perspectives was stressed, while Thailand attached much value to a multi-sectoral collaboration. All these countries, however, had a health policy implementation plan in quest of the elimination of unfair distributions of power, money, and resources. The USA planned to monitor a total of 187 social factors, the largest number among the 6 subject countries. It also had a wide range of perspectives on health inequalities, including income and disability, as well as conducting assessments using information from outside the health sector, with items assessed at various levels, including individual, regional, and national policies.

    Conclusion With reference to these approaches in other countries, for Japan's health promotion policies, we recommend: (1) grasping of health inequalities from more diversified perspectives and adopting measures to address them, (2) setting targets based on multi-level social determinants of individual behavior and health status, including individual socioeconomic status, and (3) promoting collaborative initiatives and use of indicators with entities outside the health sector.

    Download PDF (415K)
Original article
  • Yoshie YOKOYAMA, Noriko HATAKEYAMA, Nanami MURAKAMI
    2022 Volume 69 Issue 5 Pages 357-367
    Published: May 15, 2022
    Released on J-STAGE: May 24, 2022
    Advance online publication: March 16, 2022
    JOURNAL FREE ACCESS

    Objectives This study targeted public health nurses in a Japanese municipality that had newly adopted the core components of the Finnish system to provide continuous support to families with children until preschool. It sought to analyze changes in their perceptions for activities in maternal and child health care before and after the adoption.

    Methods Relevant data were collected through semi-structured focus group interviews, following an interview guide, conducted from September to October 2020. The study protocol was approved by the Ethics Committee of Osaka City University in Japan.

    Results A total of 12 public health nurses participated. Prior to the adoption of the system modelled on Finnish practice, these nurses were dedicated to addressing the risks regarding families with children (especially those at high risk) through continuous engagement. However, they were hesitant to proactively engage with families at lower risk as non-continuous, one-off engagements resulted in a patchwork response. After the system was adopted, the nurses became aware of the trust cultivated with families under their care, which included those at lower risk, that enabled them to respond to the changing needs flexibly. The nurses recognized that they had acquired the capability to notice the subtle signs of changes, engage more proactively with the families under their care, and deliver the necessary preventive interventions at an early stage. They also demonstrated joy and satisfaction derived from the growth of children and mothers under their care, as well as keen awareness of the need to improve their professional skills, even though they were busy.

    Conclusion These findings indicate that the continuous support system modelled on the core components from Finland enables public health nurses to proactively engage with families at lower risk and deliver preventive interventions at an early stage. The system also motivated Japanese public health nurses who found greater pleasure in their work.

    Download PDF (289K)
  • Yuko TOUSEN, Ryoko MIZUSHIMA, Noriko KOITAYA, Kayo KUROTANI, Jun NISHI ...
    2022 Volume 69 Issue 5 Pages 368-382
    Published: May 15, 2022
    Released on J-STAGE: May 24, 2022
    Advance online publication: March 16, 2022
    JOURNAL FREE ACCESS

    Objectives Minor health complaints related to stress, mental health, sleep, and fatigue are closely associated with each other, and their deterioration may cause lifestyle diseases. The health status of people can be predicted through a questionnaire by exploring the relationship between their state of minor health complaints and objective health status indices. Therefore, we conducted a systematic review of the relationship between a questionnaire on the state of minor health complaints and health status indices among Japanese people who have a high level of stress, which they experience on a daily basis, using epidemiological literature. Additionally, we considered items for the questionnaire which were necessary for an index development.

    Methods The PubMed database was searched for papers on “autonomic nervous system,” “sleep disorders,” “mental health and stress,” and “fatigue,” using keywords mentioned in previous studies on minor health complaints.

     The extracted research papers were screened according to the following inclusion criteria: 1) the participants were healthy Japanese people; 2) descriptions included characteristics of the target population; 3) use of analytic epidemiological study design, intervention studies, and systematic reviews; 4) minor health complaints assessed by a questionnaire; 5) evaluation of the relationship between the questionnaires for minor health complaints and the health index; and 6) written in Japanese or English. Based on this, ten papers were adopted.

    Results Of the 10 papers collected, one was a cohort study, three were case-control studies, and six were cross-sectional studies. The participants in five of them were working adults. Reports on three out of six questionnaires on stress, four out of seven on sleep, and all two on comprehensive health status showed significant associations between minor health complaints assessed by the questionnaires and the index for health status. The increase in responses about work-related stress from the questionnaire was associated with an increase in the “risk of developing depression” [odds ratio 2.96 (confidence interval: 1.04-8.42)]. Poor sleep quality was associated with an increase in “changes in autonomic index,” “number of comorbidities and the rate of depression,” and the “risk of work-related injuries.” Moreover, the health score was associated with the “autonomic nervous system index”.

    Conclusion These results suggest that a questionnaire evaluating minor health complaints should include questions about “stress,” “sleep quality,” and “comprehensive health status.” Since studies that appropriately adopted for risk of bias were limited, it is necessary to further examine these relationships by applying prospective studies such as cohort studies and intervention studies.

    Download PDF (453K)
  • Taishi TSUJI, Daisuke TAKAGI, Naoki KONDO, Yoshiko MARUYAMA, Kazushige ...
    2022 Volume 69 Issue 5 Pages 383-393
    Published: May 15, 2022
    Released on J-STAGE: May 24, 2022
    Advance online publication: March 16, 2022
    JOURNAL FREE ACCESS

    Objectives This study aimed to investigate whether health inequalities among communities would be reduced by intensively enhancing the “Kayoinoba” program in model communities where many high-risk, older adults live.

    Methods Kobe City and the Japan Gerontological Evaluation Study created a mail survey for older adults in 78 communities (community ≈ junior high school district) to conduct community diagnosis. Sixteen communities showed poor values along multiple dimensions of risk and required priority measures. From 2014 to 2019, we designated these 16 communities as model communities. Then, municipal officials and researchers cooperated to support the establishment and management of “Kayoinoba.” By using four-waves of mail survey data (in 2011, 2013, 2016, and 2019 with n=8,872, 10,572, 10,063, and 5,759, respectively), secular transitions of nine intermediate outcome indicators (three=social participation, two=social network, and four=social support) and five health outcome indicators (physical function, malnutrition, oral function, cognitive function, and depressive symptoms) were compared between model (n=16) and non-model (n=62) communities via multilevel mixed-effects linear regression analysis.

    Results In the 2011 and 2013 surveys, model communities showed poor value compared to the non-model communities in 13 of the 14 indicators. A significant interaction between the year and model/non-model communities was confirmed for four intermediate outcome indicators (sports and hobby group participation, number of friends met, and providing emotional support) and three health outcome indicators (oral function, cognitive function, and depressive symptoms). The differences were reduced or eliminated in the 2016 and 2019 surveys. For example, hobby group participation in 2011 was 29.7% vs. 35.0% in model vs. non-model communities; the difference narrowed to 35.2% vs. 36.1% (P=0.008). Similarly, providing emotional support increased from 83.9% vs. 87.0% to 93.3% vs. 93.3% (P=0.007). Depressive symptoms decreased from 31.4% vs. 27.2% to 18.6% vs. 20.3% (P<0.001).

    Conclusions Promoting community gathering places “Kayoinoba” for six years in communities where many high-risk older adults live may foster social participation, networking, and support and may help reduce health inequalities among communities.

    Download PDF (690K)
  • Isao SAITO, Kanako YAMAUCHI, Masamitsu YAMAIZUMI, Tadahiro KATO
    2022 Volume 69 Issue 5 Pages 394-402
    Published: May 15, 2022
    Released on J-STAGE: May 24, 2022
    Advance online publication: March 16, 2022
    JOURNAL FREE ACCESS

    Objective To investigate the relationship between metabolic syndrome (MetS) and stroke incidence in a rural population by a prospective cohort study over 18.6 years.

    Methods From 1996 to 1998, 4,068 subjects (aged 40-74 years) underwent a health checkup in O city, Ehime Prefecture, Japan, and 3,969 subjects were included, excluding those with a history of stroke, to determine whether they had suffered a stroke or died from stroke by the end of December 2018. The subjects were stratified into six groups on the presence of high waist circumference at baseline and the number of risk factors (0, 1, or 2 or more) for high blood pressure, dyslipidemia, and high blood glucose, according to the diagnostic criteria for MetS in Japan. Kaplan-Meier analysis of MetS survival curves and Cox proportional hazards models were used to calculate sex- and age-adjusted hazard ratios and population attributable fractions (PAFs) for total stroke, hemorrhagic stroke, and cerebral infarction.

    Results During the follow-up period, 376 patients were identified as having had a stroke; the percentage of MetS in the stroke group was 15.2% compared to 9.4% in the non-stroke group, a significant difference. The sex- and age-adjusted hazard ratios for total stroke and cerebral infarction were approximately 2-fold higher in the groups with 1 risk and 2 or more risks, regardless of waist circumference, than in the group with normal waist circumference and no risks. PAF to total stroke incidence was highest in the group with normal waist circumference and 1 risk factor (18.9%).

    Conclusions The contribution of MetS to stroke incidence was not significant. Consistent with previous findings, the risk of stroke was increased in non-obese individuals who had at least one risk factor, such as high blood pressure.

    Download PDF (342K)
feedback
Top