Despite the early widespread clinical success with cemented stems using the second generation cement technique, many changes were introduced into stem design and material. In more recent years, many early failures of cemented stems have been reported. Many of these introduced changes based on industrial investigations, including circular stem cross-section, rough surface finish, increased stem offset, modular head-neck system, PMMA pre-coating and titanium alloy, have resulted in failure due to biological diversity and reactions. Failed stems were all designed as a composite-beam system with a rough surface finish. Composite-beam stems were less tolerant of human factors, compared to those incorporating the Taper-slip system with a smooth surface finish. Consequently, new design features should be introduced prudently with extensive pre-market testing, limited clinical release, and careful post-market surveillance. By reviewing the past history of total hip replacement, we learn an important lesson in view of the relationship between industrial innovation and clinical application. In this way we can take a lesson from the evolution of total hip replacement and understand “Yesterday's Successes and Today's Failures”.
View full abstract