Both the European and Japanese ELV recycling systems incorporate the policy of sharing roles and responsibilities for the recycling of ELVs among the four types of stakeholders, i.e. vehicle users, recycling operators, the government and automakers. While Europe and Japan originally confronted similar public issues regarding ELV disposal, the two regions selected somewhat different approaches. Japan made dealing with ASR, the most costly and technically difficult step in the entire ELV recycling process, the responsibility of automakers while Europe made it the responsibility of automakers to deal with every aspect of ELVs, inclusive of ASR. In both regions, the users are asked to pay for the recycling costs either directly or indirectly, and the automakers then hire their contractors to do the actual work of dismantling, recycling and disposal.
The different approaches taken by Europe and Japan stem from careful deliberations over the design and development of a practical system that can be operated and publicly accepted over a long period of time in each social setup, having its own unique industry distribution and market makeup. In both Europe and Japan, the stakeholders have performed their roles in an effort to address the specific public issues existing in each region. For the sustained operation of the ELV recycling system additional efforts will need to be made, especially in improving the relevant laws and regulations to better match the conditions existing in Europe and Japan.
View full abstract