-
Akira MOMIYAMA
1987 Volume 1987 Issue 37 Pages
1-35,en3
Published: March 30, 1988
Released on J-STAGE: November 16, 2009
JOURNAL
FREE ACCESS
In the Chunqiu period a litigation was called
yu _??_ or
song _??_ as in later ages. Their definition in later ages is that "a larger suit is called
yu and a smaller one
song." But in the Chunqiu period they,
yu and
song, meant two different stages of one procedure of a suit;
yu was a dispute and verbal conflicts in the court between the parties, and to sit face to face for the occasion was called
zuoyu _??__??_ and to pass a judgement on the dispute
duanyu _??__??_ or
zheyu _??__??_ ;
song itself was. a procedure to originate a suit and it is found in historical materials written in a form such as "X (the plaintiff) brings Y (the accused) and appeals to Z (the judge)." This definite pattern shows the fact that there was a general practice that the plaintiff had the accused accom-panied in bringing a suit in the Chunqiu period.
The judging standard of
duanyu was the justifiability of the parties' arguments. This justifiability was called
zhi _??_ and the illegal practice of buying off the judge was called
maizhi _??__??_ or to buy
zhi. At the period there were no fulltime judges and those who were influential and celebrated filled the role of the judges at request. The parties litigant were often represented by advocates.
It may be proper to call the litigation in the Chunqiu period with these characteristics the "agonistic lawsuit." And it was closely related with the law structure peculiar to the period where the self-help was generally accepted; the "agonistic lawsuit" and the self-help of the Chunqiu period were both derived from the constitution of the period, that is, the distributed army forces which were each possessed by respective
shi _??_ in the form of
shi _??_. The cause, then, of the disap-pearance of the "agonistic lawsuit" in the time of the Imperial China may be found in the disorganization of the constitution. The highly bureaucratic litigation system of the Imperial China was a historical product born and formed with the disorganization of the constitution.
View full abstract
-
Shuzo SHIGA
1987 Volume 1987 Issue 37 Pages
37-61,en4
Published: March 30, 1988
Released on J-STAGE: November 16, 2009
JOURNAL
FREE ACCESS
This article is twinning with the same author's another article: Shiga Shuzo, "Tanshin toan no shohoteki chishiki: sosho anken ni arawareru bunsho no ruikei" (An Elementary Knowlege of the Danshui-Xinzhu Archives: Categories of Documents drawn up in Litigation Cases), in: Toyohoshi no tankyu: Shimada Masao hakase shoju kinen ronshu (Studies in Asian Legal History in Honor of Shimada Masao), Tokyo: Kyuko Shoin, 1987. Its purpose is to throw light on some aspects of traditional Chinese judicial system which can hardly be approached by the study of edited books as source materials and, in fact, dropped from the observations in the same author's former book: Shiga Shuzo, Shindai chugoku no ho to saiban (Law and Justice in Qing China), Tokyo: Sobunsha, 1984.
Efforts are made to evaluate the function of government runners who executed various types of warrant: warrants of investigation; of production of documentary evidence; of pressing performance of a duty; of conciliation; of injunction of using force; of summon; of arrest, etc.; and also to analyse in what manner each case comes to an end.
In conclusion those points are argued: 1) In discussing litigation practices, it is inadequate to bring merely the process of hearings given by the magistrate sitting in court into focus. The foregoing process conducted by dispatched government runners with warrants in their hands is also important. Both processes were of the same nature as intervention of public authorities in disputes among people and should be taken into account together with each other as a whole. 2) It is also inadequate to treat lawsuit at the magistrate office and mediation among people themselves separately as two things standing in contrast to each other. The former was also nothing but a mediating process in its nature. Both processes used to go on side by side and functioned complementary to each other.
View full abstract
-
1987 Volume 1987 Issue 37 Pages
55
Published: 1987
Released on J-STAGE: November 16, 2009
JOURNAL
FREE ACCESS
-
Sétsuo WATANABE
1987 Volume 1987 Issue 37 Pages
63-101,en5
Published: March 30, 1988
Released on J-STAGE: November 16, 2009
JOURNAL
FREE ACCESS
Dans cet article, nous avons traité des rapports concrets entre les rois et les évêchés en France aux He et 12e siècles, dans le processus de l'enforcement des pouvoirs royaux. Au milieu de ces deux siècles, se situe l'affaire historique important que l'on nomme soit "la Réforme grégorienne", soit "la Querelle des investitures". Pour résoudre notre problème correctement, it nous importe, bien sûr, de la situer just au point. Cependant, au Japon, depuis longtemps, on met, d'une part, l'accent seulement sur les relations politiques entre la Papauté et son adver-saire l'Empereur allemand de cet époque; et d'autre part, l'argument se concentre sur leurs conflits visant l'initiative de la domination sur l'Eglise.
Par contre, pour la structure des puissances, it va sans dire que la conséquence la plus importante de la Querelle consiste en la formation de la notion de "regalia" signifiant les pouvoirs séculiers accumulés chez l'évêché, et en la préparation des conditions nécessaires pour mettre celui-ci dans la structure des puissances féodo-vassaliques. Quant au déroulement de ces deux effets au 12e siècle, dans le chapitre IV, avons nous exposé les causes historiques de leur réalisation tardive en France. Surtout, nous avons insisté à ce qu'elle avait besoin précédemment de la vassalisation du prince (ou comte) laic vis-à-vis des évêques voisinants.
Nous exposons sommairement les conclusions présentées dans les trois chapitres précédents (I, II, III). Au chapitre I, nous avons éclairci qu'en France, it y a trois types de succession aux pouvoirs "publics" dévolus aux comtes carolingiens. En général, les princes (ou comtes nouveaux) laïcs y ont succédé principalement au detriment des évêques, à la différence du type "lorrain" où les évêques ont réussi à les accumuler presque exclusivement à l'aide des Empereurs allemands.
Au chapitre II, nous avons comparé, l'un à l'autre, les politiques ecclé-siastiques des rois capétiens de l'époque de la "Réforme grégorienne" (Philippe I, Louis VI, Louis VII). Nous y avons éprouvé qu'ils se sont obstinés à maintenir leur control personnel sur les évêchés avec le droit d'approuver l'évêques élus, en attendant la diffusion de la notion réelle de "regalia". Au chapitre III, nous avons traité de l'influence de la "Querelle des investitures" exercée sur le système pour dominer le royaume frangais, surtout sur la composition des agents ou des fonction-naires royaux, en nous fondant sur le changement de celle des témoins de diplômes et des présents des réunions royales.
C'est ainsi que nous avons accompli un des travaux préparatifs de nos recherches que nous allons exécuter sur la formation des pouvoirs seculiers de l'évêché de Langres, vis-à-vis de celles des nobles laÏcs de la Bourgogne septentrionale.
View full abstract
-
[in Japanese]
1987 Volume 1987 Issue 37 Pages
103-126
Published: March 30, 1988
Released on J-STAGE: November 16, 2009
JOURNAL
FREE ACCESS
-
[in Japanese]
1987 Volume 1987 Issue 37 Pages
127-136
Published: March 30, 1988
Released on J-STAGE: November 16, 2009
JOURNAL
FREE ACCESS
-
[in Japanese]
1987 Volume 1987 Issue 37 Pages
136-144
Published: March 30, 1988
Released on J-STAGE: November 16, 2009
JOURNAL
FREE ACCESS
-
[in Japanese]
1987 Volume 1987 Issue 37 Pages
144-153
Published: March 30, 1988
Released on J-STAGE: November 16, 2009
JOURNAL
FREE ACCESS
-
[in Japanese]
1987 Volume 1987 Issue 37 Pages
153-160
Published: March 30, 1988
Released on J-STAGE: November 16, 2009
JOURNAL
FREE ACCESS
-
[in Japanese]
1987 Volume 1987 Issue 37 Pages
160-162
Published: March 30, 1988
Released on J-STAGE: November 16, 2009
JOURNAL
FREE ACCESS
-
[in Japanese]
1987 Volume 1987 Issue 37 Pages
162-167
Published: March 30, 1988
Released on J-STAGE: November 16, 2009
JOURNAL
FREE ACCESS
-
[in Japanese]
1987 Volume 1987 Issue 37 Pages
167-173
Published: March 30, 1988
Released on J-STAGE: November 16, 2009
JOURNAL
FREE ACCESS
-
[in Japanese]
1987 Volume 1987 Issue 37 Pages
173-179
Published: March 30, 1988
Released on J-STAGE: November 16, 2009
JOURNAL
FREE ACCESS
-
[in Japanese]
1987 Volume 1987 Issue 37 Pages
179-185
Published: March 30, 1988
Released on J-STAGE: November 16, 2009
JOURNAL
FREE ACCESS
-
[in Japanese]
1987 Volume 1987 Issue 37 Pages
185-191
Published: March 30, 1988
Released on J-STAGE: November 16, 2009
JOURNAL
FREE ACCESS
-
[in Japanese]
1987 Volume 1987 Issue 37 Pages
191-195
Published: March 30, 1988
Released on J-STAGE: November 16, 2009
JOURNAL
FREE ACCESS
-
[in Japanese]
1987 Volume 1987 Issue 37 Pages
195-199
Published: March 30, 1988
Released on J-STAGE: November 16, 2009
JOURNAL
FREE ACCESS
-
[in Japanese]
1987 Volume 1987 Issue 37 Pages
199-201
Published: March 30, 1988
Released on J-STAGE: November 16, 2009
JOURNAL
FREE ACCESS
-
[in Japanese]
1987 Volume 1987 Issue 37 Pages
201-205
Published: March 30, 1988
Released on J-STAGE: November 16, 2009
JOURNAL
FREE ACCESS
-
[in Japanese]
1987 Volume 1987 Issue 37 Pages
205-208
Published: March 30, 1988
Released on J-STAGE: November 16, 2009
JOURNAL
FREE ACCESS
-
[in Japanese]
1987 Volume 1987 Issue 37 Pages
208-210
Published: March 30, 1988
Released on J-STAGE: November 16, 2009
JOURNAL
FREE ACCESS
-
[in Japanese]
1987 Volume 1987 Issue 37 Pages
210-212
Published: March 30, 1988
Released on J-STAGE: November 16, 2009
JOURNAL
FREE ACCESS
-
[in Japanese]
1987 Volume 1987 Issue 37 Pages
212-214
Published: March 30, 1988
Released on J-STAGE: November 16, 2009
JOURNAL
FREE ACCESS
-
[in Japanese]
1987 Volume 1987 Issue 37 Pages
214-220
Published: March 30, 1988
Released on J-STAGE: November 16, 2009
JOURNAL
FREE ACCESS
-
[in Japanese]
1987 Volume 1987 Issue 37 Pages
220-226
Published: March 30, 1988
Released on J-STAGE: November 16, 2009
JOURNAL
FREE ACCESS
-
[in Japanese]
1987 Volume 1987 Issue 37 Pages
226-230
Published: March 30, 1988
Released on J-STAGE: November 16, 2009
JOURNAL
FREE ACCESS
-
[in Japanese]
1987 Volume 1987 Issue 37 Pages
230-238
Published: March 30, 1988
Released on J-STAGE: November 16, 2009
JOURNAL
FREE ACCESS
-
[in Japanese]
1987 Volume 1987 Issue 37 Pages
238-242
Published: March 30, 1988
Released on J-STAGE: November 16, 2009
JOURNAL
FREE ACCESS
-
[in Japanese]
1987 Volume 1987 Issue 37 Pages
242-250
Published: March 30, 1988
Released on J-STAGE: November 16, 2009
JOURNAL
FREE ACCESS
-
[in Japanese]
1987 Volume 1987 Issue 37 Pages
250-253
Published: March 30, 1988
Released on J-STAGE: November 16, 2009
JOURNAL
FREE ACCESS
-
[in Japanese]
1987 Volume 1987 Issue 37 Pages
253-255
Published: March 30, 1988
Released on J-STAGE: November 16, 2009
JOURNAL
FREE ACCESS
-
[in Japanese]
1987 Volume 1987 Issue 37 Pages
255-257
Published: March 30, 1988
Released on J-STAGE: November 16, 2009
JOURNAL
FREE ACCESS
-
[in Japanese]
1987 Volume 1987 Issue 37 Pages
257-259
Published: March 30, 1988
Released on J-STAGE: November 16, 2009
JOURNAL
FREE ACCESS
-
[in Japanese]
1987 Volume 1987 Issue 37 Pages
259-261
Published: March 30, 1988
Released on J-STAGE: November 16, 2009
JOURNAL
FREE ACCESS
-
[in Japanese]
1987 Volume 1987 Issue 37 Pages
261-263
Published: March 30, 1988
Released on J-STAGE: November 16, 2009
JOURNAL
FREE ACCESS
-
[in Japanese]
1987 Volume 1987 Issue 37 Pages
263-266
Published: March 30, 1988
Released on J-STAGE: November 16, 2009
JOURNAL
FREE ACCESS
-
[in Japanese]
1987 Volume 1987 Issue 37 Pages
266-268
Published: March 30, 1988
Released on J-STAGE: November 16, 2009
JOURNAL
FREE ACCESS
-
[in Japanese]
1987 Volume 1987 Issue 37 Pages
268-270
Published: March 30, 1988
Released on J-STAGE: November 16, 2009
JOURNAL
FREE ACCESS
-
[in Japanese]
1987 Volume 1987 Issue 37 Pages
271-272
Published: March 30, 1988
Released on J-STAGE: November 16, 2009
JOURNAL
FREE ACCESS
-
[in Japanese]
1987 Volume 1987 Issue 37 Pages
272-275
Published: March 30, 1988
Released on J-STAGE: November 16, 2009
JOURNAL
FREE ACCESS
-
[in Japanese]
1987 Volume 1987 Issue 37 Pages
275-287
Published: March 30, 1988
Released on J-STAGE: November 16, 2009
JOURNAL
FREE ACCESS
-
[in Japanese]
1987 Volume 1987 Issue 37 Pages
287-293
Published: March 30, 1988
Released on J-STAGE: November 16, 2009
JOURNAL
FREE ACCESS
-
[in Japanese]
1987 Volume 1987 Issue 37 Pages
293-300
Published: March 30, 1988
Released on J-STAGE: November 16, 2009
JOURNAL
FREE ACCESS
-
[in Japanese]
1987 Volume 1987 Issue 37 Pages
300-309
Published: March 30, 1988
Released on J-STAGE: November 16, 2009
JOURNAL
FREE ACCESS
-
[in Japanese]
1987 Volume 1987 Issue 37 Pages
309-314
Published: March 30, 1988
Released on J-STAGE: November 16, 2009
JOURNAL
FREE ACCESS
-
[in Japanese]
1987 Volume 1987 Issue 37 Pages
314-316
Published: March 30, 1988
Released on J-STAGE: November 16, 2009
JOURNAL
FREE ACCESS
-
[in Japanese]
1987 Volume 1987 Issue 37 Pages
316-318
Published: March 30, 1988
Released on J-STAGE: November 16, 2009
JOURNAL
FREE ACCESS
-
[in Japanese]
1987 Volume 1987 Issue 37 Pages
318-320
Published: March 30, 1988
Released on J-STAGE: November 16, 2009
JOURNAL
FREE ACCESS
-
[in Japanese]
1987 Volume 1987 Issue 37 Pages
320-322
Published: March 30, 1988
Released on J-STAGE: November 16, 2009
JOURNAL
FREE ACCESS
-
[in Japanese]
1987 Volume 1987 Issue 37 Pages
322-325
Published: March 30, 1988
Released on J-STAGE: November 16, 2009
JOURNAL
FREE ACCESS