It is widely recognized that biomedical ethics was based on liberal individualism,
which originated in Mill’s arguments in On Liberty (1859) and reflected ethics for
strong people. Since then, importance of independence and self-determination has been
emphasized in society. However, in recent years there has been criticism to this stress
on independence seen from the viewpoint of human relationship. Critics consider the
weak side of human beings. Daniel Callahan, known for his communitarian positions,
emphasizes the importance of interdependence, and argues for the necessity of lifelong
education to understand moments of dependence on others. Martha C. Nussbaum, an
Aristotelian, posits that not only independence but also vulnerability is an excellent
principle of ethics. Max Scheler points out a way of release, which rests on the basis
of modest attitudes and recalls better human relationships. Edith Stein asserts that
relationships with others develop the potential talent in human beings. I think that these
insights of these two German phenomenology philosophers are essential in order to deal
with the problems of providing support to suffering.
View full abstract