In this paper are considered relations among the following three delay systems with gain compensation, feedback compensation or series lead compensation. They are the zero non-regular control system whose open loop transfer function has zeros in the right half S-plane (Z-system), the control system with dead time (D-system), and the control system with S-shaped lag (S-system). In these cases the zero non-regular delay, dead time or S-shaped lag is assumed to be added to the fundamental second order linear control loop. Conclusions obtained as follows:
1) The Stable domain of S-system is wider than that of D-system and the same domain of D-system is wider than that of Z-system.
2) The stability limits of D-system are approximate to those of Z-system in all cases of the three compensation methodes, so that in the design of control system with dead time, the stability limits of Z-system serves as approximate stability limits of D-system.
3) If the delay time is small, dynamic properties of the three dalay systems with gain compensation or series lead compensation are tolerably similar each other. But dynamic properties of the three delay systems with feedback compensation are not always similar each other, even if the delay time is small.
View full abstract