〔Objective〕To clarify the effectiveness of rubric application in adult nursing science and practice based on the relationship between student self-assessment and teacher assessment.
〔Method〕Participants included 58 nursing students from University A, who had received accreditation for adult nursing practices in 2014 and had given their consent to take part in the study, and eight faculty members involved in practical evaluation.
This study examined three adult nursing science and practice courses: critical stage, chronic stage, and terminal stage nursing science and practice. Rubrics were used for the assessment of adult nursing science and practice, in which common practice benchmarks and grading scales were established for all three courses, characteristics of each course were incorporated in the assessment tool and assessment criterion, and the assessment results were indicated using qualitative information.
The relationship between student self-assessment and teacher assessment was analyzed separately for each course using overall assessment scores and benchmarks of adult nursing science practice and assessment levels for each benchmark.
〔Results〕There was no difference between students and teachers in the overall assessment scores provided in any of the three adult nursing science and practice courses, showing a positive correlation.
However, in the assessment levels classified by benchmarks, the correlations found between student self-assessment and teacher assessment were rs = 0.36−0.71, indicating a difference in relationship according to the course and benchmark.
〔Discussion〕In rubrics that provide assessment criteria with qualitative information, even if there is no difference in the overall scores in the relationship between student self-assessment and teacher assessment, there are differences in the relationship based on assessment levels according to the courses and benchmarks. Our findings show that adult nursing science and practice courses and benchmarks should be examined to establish common benchmarks.
View full abstract