Testing thermodynamic consistency of vapor-liquid equilibrium data is commonly based on the Gibbs-Duhem equation under the condition of constant pressure and temperature. But the equation is under a hypothetical condition when it is used for a binary system at two-phase equilibrium, since it is shown by the phase rule that one cannot vary the concentration at constant temperature and pressure while keeping the phase equilibrium. Therefore some allowance must be made for the equilibrium data or for the equation.
In the first place, the thermodynamical equations, in which the values of heat of mixing were used for carrying out the exact test of the vapor-liquid equilibrium data at low pressures, were discussed as to their applications to experimental data, and then the methods of calculating the properties which were necessary for the exact test were shown.
By use of these thermodynamical relations and of the experimental data on heat of mixing, which had been reported in a previous paper, exact tests of vapor-liquid equilibrium data on the methanol-water and isopropanol-water systems were conducted and the activity coefficients, defined by Equation (3), of these two systems were calculated at various temperatures
The isobaric data at atmospheric pressure by Uchida-Kato on methanol-water, and by Wilson-Simons on isopropanol-water were utilized as the basic data for calculating the activity coefficients at various temperatures, as shown in Tables 1 and 2, and in Figures 5 and 13, because these data are thermodynamically self-consistent.
Isobaric and isothermal data available on methanol-water system at reduced pressures were tested of their validity by comparing the values of activity coefficient calculated from the data with the values given in Table 1. Othmer's isobaric data at 500, 350 and 200mm Hg, shown in Figures 6 and 7, appear to be reliable although these data show some inconsistencies in the area test. Similar comparisons on the isothermal data below the normal boiling point are shown in Figures8, 9, 10 and 11.
For the isopropanol-water system, the same comparisons as in the case of methanol-water system were performed on the isobaric data of Wilson-Simons at 95, 190, 380 and 3087mmHg, and good agreements were obtained between the values of activity coefficient calculated from these data and values in Table 2, proving that Wilson's data are fully reliable.
Using Tables 1, 2, and Figure 1, along with the vapor pressure data from the literature, one can calculate isothermal or isobaric x-y values for these systems at low pressures.
View full abstract