With the aim of preventing traffic accidents involving pedestrians during nighttime rainfall, we examined the visibility of umbrellas of four colors (black, navy blue, blue, and transparent) with reflective tape attached in three different patterns (four places, around the circumference, and radial), as well as without any tape attached (i.e., plain color). Twenty female students evaluated 144 image samples taken at night of a person holding an umbrella with low beam illumination at distances of 100m at 10m intervals. Comparing the four plain-colored umbrellas, the blue umbrellas had significantly higher visibility ratings at 20-40m than the black, navy blue, and transparent umbrellas (p < 0.05). However, results suggested that even when using a blue umbrella, detection of pedestrians may be delayed when cars are traveling at a speed of 60 km/h. Visibility ratings for umbrellas with reflective tape attached in a circumference or radial pattern were significantly higher than plain-colored ones and those with reflective tape attached in four places (p < 0.05). It was affirmed that attaching reflective tape in a radial and circumference pattern is effective in increasing umbrella visibility.
View full abstract