Paired catchment experiments are a useful method for determining the relationship between vegetation cover and water yield. We collected the results and detailed information of 69 watershed experiments on deforested treatments from all over the world. We characterized each catchment according to the following four aspects: vegetation type, treatment, condition of forest soil, and annual rainfall. The effects of these catchment characteristics on annual water yield changes were evaluated using the Type I Quantification Method proposed by Hayashi (1952), which is a type of multivariate regression analysis. The results showed that annual water yield changes were affected by annual rainfall, treatment, forest soil condition, and vegetation types in this sequence of degree of effect. In particular, the effect of annual rainfall was very strong. The effects of treatment and forest soil condition also had a significant influence on annual water yield changes.
Among vegetation types, the coniferous forest category showed slightly higher water yield changes compared to the hardwood forest category. An additional analysis was conducted for the same 69 watershed experiments to assess the following factors: biome and vegetation type, treatment, and condition of forest soil. We classified each of the 69 watersheds by 11 combinations of biome and vegetation type, including taiga (coniferous), temperate rainforest (coniferous), temperate rainforest (hardwood), temperate forest (coniferous), temperate forest (hardwood), temperate forest (scrub), open forest (coniferous), open forest (hardwood), open forest (scrub), Mediterranean forest (scrub), and tropical monsoon forest. The effect of each category on the annual water yield was shown as a category score. The results showed that the category score of each biome type differs. Each vegetation type in the same biome type had a different category score. In temperate rainforest and temperate forest, the category score of coniferous forests was larger than that for hardwood forests. However, in sparse woodland, the category score for coniferous forests was smaller than that for hardwood forests. We conclude that the effect of vegetation on the annual water yield depends on the type of biome.
View full abstract