In order to ascertain clinical usefulness of apalcillin (APPC) objectively, a well-controlled comparative study was performed at 99 institutions using sulbenicillin (SBPC) as the control drug in the patients of postoperative wound infections (Trial A) and postoperative localized peritonitis and/or dead space infections (Trial B).(Total number of patients were 113 in Trial A and 108 in Trial B). Either 1g of APPC or 5g of SBPC was administered to patients by i. v. drip infusion twice a day for 7 days in Trial A and 10 days in Trial B. The results obtained are as follows:
1) Overall clinical improvement rates were 91.5% in APPC group and 66.7% in SBPC group in Trial A, and 88. 7% in APPC group and 47.3% in SBPC group in Trial B. In both trials, APPC was significantly superior to SBPC.
2) When overall clinical improvement rates of both drugs were compared in subgroups divided by the depth of infections at the lesions, APPC was significantly superior to SBPC in all subgroups in both Trial A and B.
3) As to bacteriological effects, eradication rates of clinical isolates were 90% in APPC group, 50% in SBPC group in Trial A and 99% in APPC group, 51.4% in SBPC group in Trial B. Thus, APPC was significantly superior to SBPC in both Trial A and B.
4) Rates of clinical effectiveness judged by the surgeons for each patient were 86.4% in APPC group, 61.1% in SBPC group in Trial A and 75.5% in APPC group, 45.5% in SBPC group in Trial B. Thus, APPC was significantly superior to SBPC in both Trial A and B.
5) As to usefulness judged by the surgeons for each patient, APPC was significantly superior to SBPC in both Trial A and B.
6) As to elimination on improvement of clinical symptoms and findings, days needed for such elimination on improvement, and their elimination rate scored by points method, APPC was significantly superior to SBPC in all items.
7) Side effects were more frequent in SBPC group than in APPC group. This was because there were more cases of elevated GPT values in SBPC group.
When we evaluate the usefulness of APPC against post operative infections based on the above results, we can conclude APPC is obviously more useful than SBPC even at the one fifth dose of that of SBPC.
View full abstract