Since combined use of piperacillin (PIPC) and aminoglycosides (AGs) shows a synergistic effect
in vitro, a clinical examination of this combination therapy was carried out from August 1985 to January 1987 by a well controlled study. Drugs were administered at 4 g daily of PIPC alone, 120 mg of tobramycin (TOB) combined with 4 g of PIPC, or 200mg netilmicin (NTL) combined with 4 g of PIPC.
1. The clinical efficacy rates in all cases evaluated by the attending committee members were 66.0 in PIPC alone, 73.3% in PIPC combined with TOB, and 71.7% in PIPC combined with NTL, respectively. No significant difference was observed between PIPC alone and PIPC combined with AGs.
There was also no significant difference in clinical effect between PIPC alone and PIPC combined with AGs evaluated by the committee members, in patients with pneumonia or pulmonary suppuration, and with chronic respiratory tract infection.
2. Bacteriological respose against causative organisms in all cases tends to be significantly superior in PIPC combined with AGs than in single use of PIPC. Particularly in infections due to
Pseudomonas aeruginosa, the eradication rate was much superior. 20% in PIPC alone but 56% in PIPC combined with AGs.
3. There was no significant difference between PIPC alone and combined PIPC with regard to side effects or abnormality in laboratory findings.
4. There was no significant difference in usefulness between single use of PIPC and combined PIPC as evaluated by the committee members.
In conclusion, we consider that combination therapy of PIPC with AGs was more effective than PIPC alone, particularly in treating chronic respiratory tract infections due to
P. aeruginosa, and was just as safe.
View full abstract