In Tanohata village in Iwate Prefecture, we carried out the “Health Pioneer Town Project”, a health project administered dy the National Health Insurance, for 5 years between 1993 and 1997.In this project, fluoride mouth rinsing and fissure sealing of the first molars were practiced in school children. To evaluate the effects of this project, the author compared the prevalence of caries both before and after the project, and also analyzed its health economic effects by cost-benefit analysis.Regarding the prevalence of dental caries, the caries prevalence rate in primary and junior high school children markedly decreased from 69.7% to 39.6%, and the DMFT index also decreased from 3.43 to 1.36 rernarkably. In the cost-benefit analysis, the direct cost of fluoride mouth rinsing and fissure sealing was regarded as the primary cost, and the indirect cost of the practice and continuation of the project was regarded as the secondary cost. The primary cost per child per year was 233.4 yen for fluoride mouth rinsing and 726.8 yen for fissure sealing, and the secondary cost was 2703 yen. The benefit element was the reduction in the caries treatment cost. Assuming all teeth with caries treated, the treatment cost per case was standardized based on dental.insurance points. The reduction in the caries treatment cost per child per year was 2,846.9 yen in all. the primary and junior high school children, When the primary cost alone was evaluated, the cost-benefit ratio was 3.0. When the secondary cost was included, the cost-benefit ratio was 2.3.To test this analysis, the actual total dental treatment cost between the 1993 fiscal year and the 1997 fiscal year in students insured with the National Health Insurance was compared with the total caries treatment cost obtained by standardization, When the secondary cost was included, the cost-benefit ratio based on the actual total dental treatment cost was 1.2, and that based on the standardized total caries treatment cost was 2.6.This improvement in the prevalence of dental caries and the results of the health economic analysis show adequate benefits of caries prevention by fluoride mouth rinsing and fissure sealing supported by a health project of the National Health Insurance.
View full abstract