(Purpose) To validate 2009 TNM classification (7
th edition) of renal cell carcinoma (RCC), we reevaluated our RCC database depends on 6
th and 7
th TNM staging and analyzed a prognostic divergence between subgroups. (Methods) A study population of 350 patients with RCC was retrospectively reviewed based on the TNM classification both 6
th and 7
th editions. Cause-specific survival (CSS) in each group was estimated using Kaplan-Meier method. (Results) Applying the new TNM system, 336 patients were divided into pT1a 131, pT1b 105, pT2a 31, pT2b 13, pT3a 38, pT3b 3, pT3c 0, pT4 14. Previously pT3b-staged 11 cases with renal vein involvement without vena caval extension were included into pT3a. Due to the positive direct invasion into the adrenal gland, previously pT3-staged six patients were changed to pT4.Kaplan-Meier curves revealed no significant differences in CSS between each a/b subgroups from pT1 to pT3. Particularly, no significant statistical value was recognized between pT2a and pT2b subgroups. Patients with direct adrenal invasion tended to show a less favorable prognosis than those with invasion beyond Gerota. (Conclusions) 1) pT2 subdivision does not affect prognostic value. 2) Population imbalance is enhanced due to the pT3 reclassification. 3) Direct adrenal invasion is compatible with pT4 category.
View full abstract