The purpose of this study was to document the effectiveness of Weighted Noise Voice Treatment (WNVT) applying the Lombard effect, which was described in our previous report (Takahashi, Sasaki, Takahashi et al., 2002), in a 48-year-old male aphonic patient with motor and cognitive disorders after subarachnoid hemorrhage (SAH) . MRI revealed a lesion involving the right frontal lobe and the medial aspect of the left frontal lobe. The patient exhibited aphonia after SAH, with no changes in vocal conditions during the 3.5 months before treatment. Motor and cognitive disorders made it impossible for the patient to undergo pushing exercises. Vocal anomaly did not vary even when he was encouraged to speak louder. However, with weighted noise the patient exhibited improved vocal intensity and quality. The treatment started with reading short sentences aloud applying weighted noise at a level of 55 dB. The intensity of noise was gradually decreased in tandem with recovery from the voice disorder. After 4 months of treatment the patient exhibited improved vocal condition, but mild breathiness remained.
This study suggests that WNVT is effective for improving vocal intensity and quality in patients with hypofunctional voice disorders associated with cerebrovascular disease, as even patients with motor and cognitive disorders are able to receive this treatment. Here, a case study is reported and the effectiveness of WNVT is evaluated.
View full abstract