Simultaneous occurrence of gastric and duodenal ulcer has drawn many attentions in the past. Most of the studies concerning this combined ulcers, however, is the radiographic discription and no detail of the behavior has been well documented.
In view of this, an attempt was made to analyse their clinical, radiographic and laboratory findings in combined ulcers to elucidate their characteristics.
A total of 291 of combined ulcers were observed at the Icho-Hospital in Tokyo from 1950 to 1959. Among these, 220 cases were diagnosed by X-ray, and 71 cases were confirmed at the operation. In 94 cases, the pre and post ulcer studies were available. Besides of these combined ulcers, a total of 32 cases with an alternative gastric and duodenal ulcer were subjected for the study.
The frequency of the combined ulcer The combined ulcers occurred in 4.9% of the total peptic ulcer cases and it was found one in every 8.2 and 11.4 cases of gastric and duodenal ulcer respectively. Although the incidence of gastric ulcer has been decreasing and that of the duodenal ulcer has been increasing at this hospital in the past several years, the frequency of the combined ulcers has neither tendency.
The sexual distribution of the combined ulcer
The sexual difference in the occurrence of the combined ulcers is similar to that of the duodenal ulcer and it was found 7.1 times greater among male than female.
The age distribution of the combined ulcer Although in general, the duodenal ulcer is more common among younger group of the patients, no characteristic of combined ulcers was found.Syomptoms of the combined ulcer
There may be a hunger epigastric pain typical of the duodenal ulcer but nocturnal pain is very infrequent. Nausea, vomiting, melena, hematemesis and positive occult blood are more common and more pronounced in the combined ulcer than those in gastric and duodenal ulcer alone.
X-ray findings of the combined ulcer
The size of the gastric ulcer occurring in cases of the combined ulcer is smaller than that in the usual gastric ulcer. On the other hand, no definite crater was seen in duodenum in csses of the combined ulcer. Sixty-five percents of these deformity has been proved to have an active duodenal ulcer in our previous report. Thus it seems to indicate that the observation of the crater in the duodenum is not absolutely necessaryin making the diagnosis of the combined ulcer. In contrary to the statement of Johnson and Dragstedt, only 8% of the combined ulcer had pyloric stenosis. In 34 cases in which the pre and post ulcer studies were available, 20 cases of the duodenal ulcer preceded by the gastric ulcer.
Clinicalcourse
There was no case in which the simultaneous healing of both gastric and duodenal ulcer was noted. In general, gastric ulcer occurring in the combined ulcer heals faster than that of the duodenum but on the other hand, the frequency of the reoccurrrence of the ulcer was also greater in gastric ulcer than duodenal ulcer. In 71 cases with formation of the operation data, there was a tendency of multiple gastric ulcers which is agreeable with the findings of Ohi, Ito and Comfort.
Histological examination was made in 31 cases of the combined ulcer, no difference was noted in comparison to the usual type of either gastric or duodenal ulcer.
In conclusion, no definite difference was found in the behavior of the each ulcer in cases of combined and usual peptic ulcer after the follow up stuies of the combined ulcer.
View full abstract