Agricultural co-operative marketing, referred to as 'nokyo-kyohan': includes not only marketing conducted by agricultural co-operatives but also collective marketing by farmers themselves. Although nokyo-kyohan had been effective and efficient in an open market system symbolized by central wholesale markets, it is losing effectiveness and efficiency due to structural changes of a alliance market system lead by big supermarket chains along with changes of their inner structure in a diversification of members. An open market system was common from the 1960's to the 1980's, a time of demand expansion of agricultural products in Japan characterized by mass distribution, competitive advantages for wholesale markets and agricultural co-operatives associations. In such a system, nokyo-kyohan aspires toward volume and market share at higher prices. The features of the nokyo-kyohan - homogeneous farmer group, equal participation by members, autonomous governance, management by member representatives, payment depending on shipping volume - fit well to the open system. The alliance market system, major from 1990's in the time of decreasing demands, is characterized by competitive advantage and channel power of big retail chains. In such a system, channel leaders expect suppliers not only supply quantity stability but also quality and price stability, on-time arrival, and 'new' products. Hence, suppliers' sources of competitive advantage trend from 'quantity' and toward such 'stable supply' capabilities. In this system, the nokyo-kyohan exposes the weakness of a multi-layer structure consisting of farmers organization, agricultural co-operatives, and association. In addition, the diversification of farmers in their organization causes difficulties of sharing of goals and equal treatment of members, and weakens capabilities toward 'stable supply' to the market. Nokyo-kyohan is needed to make up 'core functions' of marketing in a multi-layered supply system and restructure farmers organizations corresponding to members' diversifications.
View full abstract