The purpose of this study was to investigate the causes of children's errors on arithmetic word problems. In the first experiment, 55 fourth graders solved two-step word problems with and without extraneous information, and with and without the needs to convert measurement units. The problem solving process was divided into five sub-processes : 1. reading, 2. understanding, 3. choice of operarions, 4. execution, and 5. checking. A personal computer was used to display the instructions, problems and item choices and to record children's responses and their response times. In the second experiment, booklets were given to 145 fourth-graders to assess in detail their sub-processes in the selection of information. The booklet contained problems with and without extraneous information. The results were analyzed mainly in two ways : the number of correct responses, and the sub-processes where the first error occurred. The main findings were as follows : Measure unit conversion tended to increase errors in the solution process, whereas in those problems without measure conversion errors broke out most frequently in the sub-process of information selection and choice of operations. Additionally, Extraneous information tended to increase errors in the sub-process of information selection. These data indicate that the process of information selection and combination play crucial roles in childlen's solutions to word problem.
View full abstract