The aim of this paper is to clarify how high school students' participation in extracurricular activities has expanded and how the expansion of participation is connected with changes in their learning behavior.
The expansion of extracurricular activities has become a social issue, and a large number of researchers have investigated how these activities have increased recently in Japan and the various problems they cause. However, there are several issues which are important but have not been examined by previous research. Primarily, it is not clear what kind of students came to participate in extracurricular activities. Secondly, the relationship between the expansion of extracurricular activities and the historical change of students' learning behavior has not been investigated. Addressing these issues will provide fundamental information for the reform of extracurricular activities and hints for a more meaningful academic life for high school students.
This paper analyzed the 1st and 4th Basic Surveys on Learning (High School Students Edition), conducted in 1990 and 2006 by the Benesse Educational Research and Development Institute. Comparing the results calculated with these two surveys, it was clarified that middle-level high school students became more likely to participate in extracurricular activities. The participation rate has increased overall, but especially in middle-level high schools. However, there was no difference in the increase of the participation rate between high social classes and others.
In addition, the relationship between participation in extracurricular activities and learning behavior has changed dramatically, and the change differs between top-level high schools and middle-level high schools. At top-level high schools in 1990, there were a certain number of students who concentrated on studying, but these students have decreased in number, while more students focus on both studies and extracurricular activities. At middle-level high schools, while in 1990 a large number of students worked hard only at their studies, the number of students who concentrate only on extracurricular activities has increased considerably. That is to say, while extracurricular activities expanded as an addition to learning at top-level high schools, they expanded as an alternative to learning at middle-level high schools.
These results suggest an important change in high school students' subculture. In Japan, it has been pointed out that, until the 1980s, there was a learning-centered culture, so that a wide range of students studied hard. The culture did not allow students to concentrate on extracurricular activities without studying hard. However, from the 2000s on, the learning-centered culture was replaced by a extracurricular activities-centered culture. In this culture, a wide range of students came to participate in extracurricular activities, on which they have been allowed to concentrate without studying hard. This may be a new culture generated as a result of the introduction of an entrance exam system that allows students to enter colleges through means other than test scores.
View full abstract