Recently we have noticed that many young patients, diagnosed as ankle instability, tended to complain not only of ankle pain, but also of other arthralgia. Consequently, it appeared to us that these arthralgia were based on general joint laxity. So we conducted a comparative study between general joint laxity devised by Kuriyama (1984) and ankle instability.
Fifty-eight cases (116 ankles) of general joint laxity, whose ages were from 12 to 29 years old (average, 18. 1 yrs.), male 5 cases, female 53 cases, were investigated. They were classified under 3 different categories;
A) Those with a history of ankle sprain (37 cases: 56 ankles: 48.3 %).
B) Those with more than 3 years involvement in sports (40 cases: 80 ankles: 69.0 %).
C) Those with no experience or less than 3 years involvement in sports (18 cases: 36 ankles: 31.0 %).
All 3 categories went through the following tests; stress X-ray (anterior talar displacement: ATD, talar tilt angle: TTA), and swing of center of gravity (C. O. G.) on one leg standing (SD AREA, Root Mean Sqare: RMS). Results of these tests were compared to that of normal ankles (ATD: 30 ankles, ADT: 200 ankles, swing of C. O. G.: 50 ankles) without general joint laxity and ankle sprain.
Of the 40 cases in Group B, 30 cases (46 ankles, 57.5 %) had a history of ankle sprain. Of the 18 cases in Group C, 7 cases (10 ankles, 27.8 %) had a history of ankle sprain. From these data, it appeared that ankle sprain is connected with a person's involvement in sports (p < 0.01).
In addition, the results. showed that despite their involvement in sports, the 32 cases in Group A showed significantly larger range in stress X-ray and swing of center of gravity compared with normal ankles (p < 0.01), while those without any history of ankle sprain showed normal range.
These findings suggested that the history of ankle sprain was closely related to the ankle instability in the cases of general joint laxity and that a person with general joint laxity received sprain easily through sports or other physical activities.
View full abstract