To investigate the excitability of spinal motor neurons and evaluate neural and motor functions in patients with cerebrovascular disease (CVD), we studied the relationship between the characteristic appearances of the H-reflex and F-wave and neurological signs. We examined the H-reflex and F-wave of the affected arm during muscle relaxation in 26 patients (12 males and 14 females) with hemiplegia caused by CVD. The mean age of the patients was 54.2 (± 13.2) years. H-reflex and F-wave with increased stimulus intensity after the median nerve stimulation at the wrist were recorded from the opponens pollicis muscle during rest on the affected side. Appearance of the H-reflex and F-wave with increased stimulus intensity was separated into four types as follows:
Type 1 : F-wave appeared with increased stimulus intensity, but there was no H-reflex.
Type 2 : H-reflex and F-wave both appeared with increased stimulus intensity, but the F-wave followed disappearance of the H-reflex with increased stimulus intensity.
Type 3 : H-reflex and F-wave both appeared with increased stimulus intensity, but the F-wave appeared during the H-reflex with increased stimulus intensity.
Type 4 : Only the H-reflex appeared with increased stimulus intensity, and there was no F-wave.
Neurological findings including muscle tone, tendon reflex and Brunnstrom motor function test (upper extremity and finger) were also evaluated. Findings on muscle tone and tendon reflex were classified into increased, normal and decreased. Those on Brunnstrom motor function test were classified into 4 groups (stages I・II, III・IV・V, VI).
Results were analyzed as follows; 1) the characteristic appearances of H-reflex and F-wave, and 2) the relationship between characteristic appearances of waves and neurological signs.
The characteristic appearances of the H-reflex and F-wave with severely increased muscle tone and increased tendon reflex were almost type 4. Those with moderately increased signs in these parameters demonstrated type 2 or 3. Those with slightly increased signs in these parameters demonstrated type 1 or 2. Those with normal findings were type 1. Those with decreased signs in these parameters showed type 1 or disappearance of the H-reflex and F-wave. The characteristic appearances of the H-reflex and F-wave were, generally speaking, related to the grade on Brunnstrom motor function test.
These findings suggest that the characteristic appearances of the H-reflex and F-wave reflect spinal motor function and can be used to evaluate the therapeutic effects of neurophysiological management on spinal motor excitability in patients with CVD.
View full abstract