The Modified Tardieu Scale (MTS) is an index for assessing muscle spasticity, and consists of measurement of Range of Motion (ROM) and Quality of Muscle Reaction (QMR). MTS is characterized by its measurement method where subject's position and velocity of muscle stretch are provided. There are a large number of research articles using MTS for parameters in western countries, but not in Japan, and little is known on its reliability and clinical usefulness. For the purpose of investigating clinical usefulness of the MTS for assessment of plantarflexors in hemiplegic patients, we analyzed the intrarater and interrater reliability of ROM and QMR (n = 13), relevance between QMR during muscle stretch at different velocities (n = 28), and relavance between QMR and Modified Ashworth Scale (MAS) (n = 30). We stretched plantarflexors of the subjects as slow as possible (V1) and as fast as possible (V3) in knee extension and flexion positions.
As a result, 1) the intrarater and interrater reliability of ROM was high (ICC = 0.98 - 0.99), and those of QMR was also high (intrarater: κ = 0.73 - 1.00, interrater: κ = 0.71 - 1.00), 2) QMR at V1 indicated a weak positive correlation to QMR at V3 in knee extension position (r
s = 0.39), and no correlation in knee flexion position. 3) QMR at V1 showed a strong positive correlation to MAS (r
s = 0.89 - 0.90), but QMR at V3 showed a weak positive correlation to MAS (r
s = 0.34 - 0.38).
The present study indicates that MTS has a high intrarater and interrater reliability, and that QMR is possibly applied for the assessment of peripheral and neural components of spasticity. The results suggest the clinical usefulness of MTS for the assessment of plantarflexors in hemiplegic patients.
View full abstract