In order to investigate the effects of self-instruction on young children's persistence at task-performance, two experiments were conducted. Exp.1 was designed to examine how success, failure and neutral experiences, as antecedent ones, would influence young children's persistence in sequent task performance. Exp.2 was designed to inspect to what extent self-instruction would affect young children's persistence at task performance with the same conditions as the least task achieving group in Exp.1. Therefore, each experiment consists of a pretest and a test of persistence. The tasks in the experiments were to untie dark brown elastic (diameter 2mm) knots. However, the firmness of the knots differed wiith the experimental groups. In Exp.1, 96 subjects aged 4-6, equal number of each sex were randomly assigned to one of three experimental groups and one control group. The pretest in Exp.1 was carried out to create a 100 percent success group by untying 4 loose knots, a 50 percent success group by untying 2 loose knots and 2 impossibly tight knots and a 0 percent succes (failure) group by untying 4 impossibly tight knots. After the pretest, all the Ss took the test of persistence, i.e., to untie 5 firm knots, each S individually. The measurement of persistence was the number of knots the subjects untied. The results from the test of persistence in Exp.1 were: the failure group < the control group < the 50 percent success group < the 100 percent success group. Since the failure group was the least achieving group, the failure experience+self-instruction group was made in Exp.2. Moreover, in order to compare the influence of similar antecedent experiences with dissimilar ones in sequent task performance in relation to the children's persistence, "untie knots" task was replaced by "fix-up puzzle" task in the pretest of Exp.2. 72 subjects were assigned to three experimental groups,i,e., the failure in similar task+self-instruction group, the failure in dissimilar task+self-instruction group, and the failure in dissimilar task group. The results of the children's persistence in Exp.2 were : the failure in similar task group < the failure in dissimilar task group < the failure in similar task+self-instruction group < the failure in dissimilar task+self-instruction group. The results, therefore, indicated the effect of self-instruction on the children's persistence was fairly strong, and the influence of antecedent experiences on sequent task-performance was distinctly positive in the similar task conditions but not in the dissimilar ones. The girls' persistence was better than the boys' except in the self-instrution group.
View full abstract