The purpose of this study was to investigate how teacher's questions would effect student's standpoint.
Experiment I
The Ss were 120 sfudents, from a junior high school, divided into three condition groups. Most of the Ss believed Lamarchism as a course of Evolution.
The Ss were told,“Lamarchism is wrong.”(Condition),“An acquired character is not inherited.” (Condition II), and “Evolution would happen by Salutation.” (Condition III).
Three indexes were examined:
1) The questions concerning the information.
2) The choiceo f Ss to choose the most interesting item from the following 6 itoms,(a) approval of Lamarchism,(b) denial of Lamarchism,(c) the right theory,(d) the role of environment in Evolution,(e) illustrations for Evolution,(f) othor theories.
3) Retention of the information:(a) the mistake in Lamarchism,(b) the mistake in Dawinism,(c) the right theory.
The results were as follows:
1) The Ss of Condition II asked more questions than the other two groups, and the Ss of Condition I asked the least.
2) Tho Ss of Condition I were much more interested in the right theory than the others.
3) About the wrongness in Lamarchism, Condition I showed much better retention than Condition II and Condition III.
The Ss are 175 college students, divided into 3 conditions as Experiment I, and each conditionhas two (No-Example & Example) groups. In order to strengthen student's belief Lamarchism, two examples are given to the example groups.
The first index is the Ss'responses to teacher's questions. The other 3 indxes are the same as Experiment I.
The results are:
1) In condition I, the Ss of both groups are astonished, shocked, and disappointed. In Condition II, the Ss in both groups have conflict responses. In Condition IIi, the Ss of both groups only showed interest in salutation.
2) In Condition I, the No Example groups ask more questions than the Example groups, but in the other two conditions the results are vice versa. The Example groups ask most questions in Condition III, and least in Condition I. On the other hand, the No-Example groups ask most questions in Condition I, but least in conditionIII. The No-Example groups in condition I want to know the correct theory about Evolution, but still consider Lamarchism to be right.
3) In Condition I, Most of the Ss are more interested in the evidence denying Lamarchism-
4) About “the wrongness in Lamarchism”, the retention of both groups in Condition I And Condition II are better that in Condition III. And “the right theory” No-Example group in Condition I has better retention than the Example group.
View full abstract