The present study was designed to examine the development of metamemorial ability in mentally retarded and nonretarded children. Three kinds of tasks, looking, recognition readiness, and recall readiness, were given to all subjects and their studying time and study behaviors were observed. It was expected that if a child had the knowledge that the recall task is more difficult than the recognition task, he would spend a longer time and try more strategies to enhance his memory at the recall task than at the recognition task. The subjects were 12 younger (MA 6 years) and 10 older (MA 10 years) mentally retarded children who attended special classes and 49 younger (MA 6 years) and 41 older (MA 10 years) normal children who attended regular classes. Three different lists of line drawings of ten common objects were employed for each subject. Ten items were mounted in a row on an 8×70cm white presentation card to make a list. A presentation apparatus was prepared. This had ten doors located in a row at the top. The subject could open one door at a time to see the item behind the door. The experiment was run individually. First, the subject was given the looking task with the instruction, "Please open these doors and see if every door has a picture behind it. And as soon as you finish your task, let me know by raising your hand." The subject's studying time and study behaviors, i.e. rehearsal and self-checking, were recorded. When the subject finished looking at the items and raised his hand, he was required to recall the items freely. Following this task, half of the subjects were given recall readiness and then the recognition readiness tasks. The other half of the subjects were given the two tasks in the reverse order. At the beginning of the recall readiness task, the subject was instructed that he could freely study the items for a future recall test. At the recognition readiness task, the subject was given free study time for the future recognition test. The experimenter stressed the difference of task format between the two readiness tasks by saying, "This time you'll have to remember and tell all of the items by yourself. No hint will be given. (This time I'll show you many cards one by one. Your task then is to identify which of the pictures are the ones you have remembered during the study period.)" The subject's studying time and study behaviors were recorded. The results showed that there was no significant difference in studying time or study behaviors between the retarded and non-retarded children when MA matching was done. MA 6 children spent a shorter time in the looking task than in the two readiness tasks and no difference was found between these tasks. MA 10 children spent a significantly longer time in order of the recall, the recognition, and the looking task. MA 10 children used more rehearsal strategies than MA 6 children. Rehearsals were more often used in order of the recall, the recognition, and the looking tasks. These results suggested that MA 6 children could differentiate between looking and memorizing but could not between recall and recognition.
View full abstract