This study examined communicative effect as a prerequisite for replacing problem behavior maintained through escape from a difficult task with functionally equivalent assistance-seeking behavior. Participants were two children with developmental delays who exhibited problem behavior in an instructional setting. In Experiment 1, two kinds of assistance-seeking behavior, assumed to have different levels of communicative effect, were trained: (A) specifying assistance, and (B) not specifying assistance. Training was done by manipulating the reinforcement efficiency of this behavior to be higher than the problem behavior. The results showed that these two assistance-seeking behaviors replaced the problem behavior equally in both children. In Experiment 2, a naive trainer's assistance was assessed across the two kinds of assistance-seeking behaviors. Also, the occurrence of problem behavior, and its correlation with the level of assistance, were analyzed. The results indicated that there was a difference between the children. However, the trainer's assistance, that is, reinforcement efficiency, was higher for the "A" behavior, specifying assistance, than for the "B" behavior, which did not specify assistance. The problem behavior recurred if a low level of assistance was received. The results are discussed in relation to the selection of alternative communicative behavior to replace problem behavior, in the light of its communicative effect.
View full abstract