It is well known that language disorder is one of the most important defects of autistic children. The purpose of this study is to analyze their language disorder from the neurolinguistical point of view based on A.R. Luria, who described two types of aphasia, dynamic and semantic, that have features opposing to each other. According to Luria, the patient of dynamic aphasia shows great difficulty in recalling verbs and constructing a sentence and the patient of semantic aphasia shows great difficulty in recalling nouns and understanding logico-grammatical structures. In this study, we have examined our hypothesis that autistic children have a similar type of language disorder to that of the patient of dynamic aphasia. The study consists of two experiments. In experiment I, subjects were 10 autistic children aged from 9 to 18, 52 mentally retarded children aged from 7 to 15 and 40 normal children aged from 6 to 10. The experiment was composed of sentence construction task and logico-grammatical cognition task. In the former task, they were instructed to make one sentence using three words given (containing 6 sub-tests). In the latter task, they were instructed to answer the questions based on logico-grammatical cognition (containing 10 sub-tests). As a result, autistic group have shown the lowest mean score in sentence construction task. This result is consistent with our hypothesis. In experiment II, the task was easier than the above to obtain more autistic subjects. Subjects were 20 autistic children aged from 7 to 18, 20 mentally retarded children aged from 8 to 19 and 36 normal children aged from 3 to 6. They were given two kinds of language task; one at word level and the other at sentence level. In the former task, subjects were asked to predicate the action in picture cards (20 verb card tests) and to name the objects in picture cards (20 noun card tests). In the latter task, divided into two parts, they were asked to predicate what is happening in picture cards (containing 10 sub-tests), and secondly, they were asked to arrange or select the picture cards based on their comprehension of different relationships between what have been instructed (containing 20 sub-tests). The results were as follows: 1) The mean score of noun card tests in autistic group was the highest and that of verb card tests was the lowest. These results are consistent with our hypothesis. 2) In picture predication tests, autistic group showed the lowest mean score, and this is also consistent with our hypothesis. 3) Autistic subjects showed great difficulty in making a sentence with correct JOSHI (particles) in the tests above. Mentally retarded group showed the same difficulty, but not so much as autistic group did. In the group of normal subjects, however, such responses couldn't be found as often. 4) The results of relationship comprehension tests did not show a significant difference among the three groups. 5) The correlation between verb card and noun card tests performance was significant in normal and retarded group, but not significant in autistic group.
View full abstract