Sports are said to be strongly associated with the values of masculine domination. In Japan, rigorous disciplines and entrenched customs—such as corporal punishment, violence, hazing, punitive running, and the enforced shaving of heads—continue to prevail within sports club activities and educational settings. These irrational practices, along with the perpetuation of masculine domination, remain persistent features of the sports world. This paper advances two sociological approaches aimed at transforming the relationship between sports and masculine domination.
The first approach employs the concept of articulation, proposing a reinterpretation of traditional customs and power relations, which have traditionally been perceived as educational issues, as ‘misrecognitions.’ It suggests rearticulating these within the different contexts of human rights violation and health. Through these discursive practices, the unjust traditional customs lose their legitimacy.
Second, this paper utilizes Pierre Bourdieu’s concept of “symbolic violence” to elucidate how masculine domination is an integral component of the broader symbolic domination embedded within the structural framework of society at large. Through this analysis, the paper seeks to uncover the structural issues underpinning masculine domination within the sports world and to explore the necessity of a consciousness-raising effort aimed at transforming the symbolic dimensions of masculine domination, which often remain unnoticed by the public.
Furthermore, this paper presents a case study examining a young male student who, lacking proficiency in sports, endeavors to assert his identity and seek retribution against sports-oriented males by aspiring to become an intellectual. In addition, using data from a nationwide university student survey, this study undertakes a comparative analysis of the cultural and social capital, as well as the habitus, of sportsoriented male students who embody masculine-dominant values, against those of “otaku” and subcultural types. The findings indicate that core athletic students exhibit the lowest reading rates and the lowest position in cultural capital. They also have exclusive and conservative values and a strong sense of gender role division of labor, as well as self-confidence. The analysis reveals how young sports-oriented men are more likely to cultivate masculine values through sports and why it is so difficult to break away from these values.
View full abstract