In a cold area (Sakata. Japan), a ground source heat pump system and an air source heat pump system for greenhouse heating were compared. Results obtained were as follows.
1)Air temperature of a greenhouse equipped with the ground source heat pump system was maintained at heating set point (14 ℃). On the other hand, air temperature of a greenhouse with the air source heat pump system could not keep the same set point, and it ranged from 7 to 14 ℃. This suggests that heating capacity of the ground source heat pump system was 67 % higher than the air source heat pump system, which had the same official compressor output as the air source heat pump system.
2)System
COP of the ground source heat pump system was stable and its average was 3.89. Using average hourly heat transfer coefficient obtained from the analysis of the ground source heat pump system, system
COP of the air source heat pump system was evaluated. And it ranged from 1.8 to 2.5 and its average was 2.14.
3)Compressor electric power consumption of the ground source heat pump system was over 30 % less than the air source heat pump system. Although total electric power consumption of the ground source heat pump system contained not only compressor and condenser fan-coil, but also circulation pump, it was 22 % less than the air source heat pump system.
View full abstract