We have been trying to evaluate dairy production systems from not only economy but also fossil energy input and nitrogen surplus.
In our previous paper the evaluation from three indexes was made on A-district having grass land dairy production. In this paper the same evaluation was also made on B-district having mixed production area of up-land crop and milk, and the comparison between A and B district are made.
As results, stocking rate is a lot higher in B-district (2.5±0.7) than A-district (1.4±0.4 [herd/ha]). Milk yield per cow per year was larger in B-district (7.8±1.0) than A-district (6.9±1.2 [t/milking cow]). B-district has more intensive farming than A-district.
Therefore, net agricultural income per unit operating area is higher in B-district (395±145) than A-district (212±84 [1, 000yen/ha]). However, net agricultural income ratio as an index of economical efficiency was lower in B-district (30±8) than A-district (36±10 [t/milking cow]).
Fossil energy input per ha was 39±14 in A-district and 91±32 [GJ/ha] in B-district. Fossil energy input output ratio as an index of energy efficiency is 2.0±0.5 in A-district and 2.4±1.5 in B-district. Nitrogen surplus per ha is 106±51 in A-district and 268±93 [GJ/ha] in B-district.
[Energy input/Net agricultural income] ratio, which means how much of fossil energy is consumed to earn 1, 000yen of net agricultural income, is higher in B-district (267±172) than A-district (210±117 [MJ/1, 000yen]).
[Nitrogen surplus/Net agricultural income] ratio which means how much of nitrogen is unutilized inside the farm to earn 1, 000yen of net agricultural income, is higher in B-district (0.8±0.5) than A-district (0.6±0.4 [kg/1, 000yen]).
B-district had higher evaluation in terms of economy. On the other hand, A-district has higher evaluation in terms of energy and nitrogen surplus. In other words, A-district seems to have higher evaluation from the environmental issues.
Although a district having higher net agricultural income had been evaluated as a better farming area for long time. It is revealed the district can be evaluated differently by applying the other evaluation indexes related to environmental issue.
View full abstract