Topical fluoride gel for caries prevention have been extensively accepted in clinical and public health programs because it is easy to apply.
Recently, the utilization of fluoride thixotropic gel has reported in several papers. However, the properties of the gel are still obscure. I have investigated the applicability of microcrystalline cellulose (MCC) as a gelling agent for fluoride application. MCC has thixotropic properties in itself, and is utilized in the food and drug industries.
The purpose of this study was to find a suitable thixotropic fluoride gel for its bioavailability and to assess fluoride release from the gel and fluoride uptake by enamel.
Experiments were performed to compare the physical and chemical properties of gels prepared in this experiment (EFG group: EFG-1-7) and commercial fluoride gels (CFG group: CFG-1-3). Experimental fluoride gels contain 5 to 7 percent of MCC as a gelling agent and 1 to 2 percent of sodium fluoride and other additives. As a conventional gel, two commercial fluoride agents (Fluorident gel and Gel II) were adopted and a fluoride thixotropic gel (Checkmate) was also compared with the EFG group.
For evaluation of physical properties of the gels, measurements were made of viscosity, thixotropy, adhesiveness, and adhesive residues of the EFG and CFG groups. To ascertain chemical properties, fluoride release and fluoride uptake by enamel were compared in the two groups.
The hysteresis loop of the gels as a thixotropic property was observed with a cone-plate rheometer. CFG-3 (Checkmate) showed a characteristic pattern of the loop and the experimental fluoride gel (EFG-7) also displayed an acceptable pattern. Experimental findings in regards to adhesiveness and adhesive resides showed that EFG-7 was superior to the CFG group in contact to tooth surfaces, in penetrating between the teeth, and in leaving a minium residue of the gel in oral retention.
Fluoride release of EFG-7 obtained 80 percent as much F
- as did the solution (APF) in the first minutes. In contrast to EFG-7, CFG-3 released only 0.2 percent fluoride.
Regarding fluoride uptake by enamel, mean fluoride concentration in teeth treated with EFG-7 was 21, 702 ppm (depth: 0.5μm) and 2, 405ppm (depth: 7.2μm), and that of CFG-3 was 2, 483 ppm (depth: 0.9μm) and 731 ppm (depth: 7.3μm).
These results indicate that the fluoride prepared in this experiment with microcrystalline cellulose has acceptable bioavailability with thixotropic properties, improving on the conventional gel and having greater fluoride uptake by enamel than the thixotropic gel of a commercial agent (CFG-3).
View full abstract