The purpose of this study was to examine the effect of phosphoric acid-acidified ammonium fluoride solution (900ppmF^-, pH 4.5) on artificial caries lesion formation. It was compared with the effect of acidulated phosphate fluoride (APF) solution. Spacimens of intact human enamel were immersed and stirred in 3 kinds of solution at 37℃ for 1 hour. The three solutions were as follows : (1) phosphric acid-acidified ammonium fluoride solution-NH_4F group, 900ppmF^-, pH 4.5 ; (2) acidulated phosphate fluoride solution-APF group, 900ppmF^-, pH 4.5; (3) cde-ionized water-control group. Artificial caries lesions were formed with demineralizing solution according to Moreno (1974), consisting of 50% synthetic hydroxyapatite saturated lactate buffer (pH 4.5). SEM observation, contact microradiogram (CMR), polarized light microscopy (PLM), and X-ray microbeam diffractometry were performed. In the APF and the NH_4F group, the results were as follows, SEM microphotographs showed many spherical crystals deposited on the surface after flouride treatments. The quantity of spherical crystals was same in the two groups. No crystals were found in the control group. After lesion formation, granular and needle-like deposits were observed on lesion surfaces. The surfaces were smoother than in the control group. It seems that the crystals were formed after immersion. CMR and PLM showed deep demineralization lesions with thin remineralised layer in the control group. In the NH_4F group, the demineralized layers were thinner than control group. In the APF group, the demineralized layers were unclear and thinner than in the NH_4F group. The layer depth was about 20μm in the APF group, about 40μm in the NH_4F group, and about 100μm in the control group. This depth was estimated by doing an EPMA analysis of SEM photographs of cross sections of the lesions. The microbeam X-ray diffraction pattern of the caries lesions showed hydroxyapatite in all groups. In the fluoride group, crystallinity of the lesions was higher than in the control group, and was the same as that of sound enamel. Therefore the cariostatic effect was APF≧NH_4F>control. These findings suggest that enamel immersed in NH_4F solution could be protected from artificial caries formation.
View full abstract