Several options are available for surgical treatment of unilateral vocal fold paralysis, and these are mainly classified into vocal fold injection surgery and laryngeal framework surgery.
When we perform vocal fold injection surgery and laryngeal framework surgery under general anesthesia, intraoperative voice monitoring is impossible.
Laryngeal framework surgery can be performed under local anesthesia, and when performed under local anesthesia, it allows fine adjustment of the surgical procedure by means of intraoperative voice monitoring. For that reason, in our clinic we have traditionally performed laryngeal framework surgery under local anesthesia.
In this article we review the 110 cases in which laryngeal framework surgery was used to treat unilateral vocal fold paralysis between 1994 and 2006 at the Isshiki Clinic of the Kyoto Voice Surgery Center. The patients consisted of 66 men and 44 women with a mean age of 52.9 years. The paralysis was on the left side in 68.2% of the cases and on the right side in the other 31.8%. The causes of the paralysis included thyroid cancer surgery, esophageal cancer surgery, lung cancer surgery, mediastinal surgery, brain tumor, and idiopathic.
Maximum phonation time (MPT) and the alternating current/direct current ratio (AC/DC ratio) were used for pre- and post-operative voice evaluation.
Arytenoid adduction (AA) was added when the glottal space was wide, and thyroplasty type I (type I) when the glottal space was narrow. When vocal fold closure was insufficient, thyro-plasty type IV (type IV) was also performed. Which of these procedures to perform was determined based on the result of intraoperative voice monitoring.
The procedures performed were : type I alone in 45 cases, type I + type IV in 13 cases, AA alone in 6 cases, AA + type I in 39 cases, and AA + type I + type IV in 7 cases.
The mean MPT of the 110 patients was 5.9 seconds before surgery and 13.5 seconds after surgery. The AC/DC ratios of the 42 patients treated since June 2004 were calculated. The mean ratio before surgery was 24.4%, and the mean ratio after surgery was 46.2%.
Among the procedures for unilateral vocal fold paralysis, laryngeal framework surgery under local anesthesia provides definite therapeutic benefit and efficacy.
View full abstract