Objective: The purpose of this study is to compare the prognosis of definitive chemoradiotherapy for advanced hypopharyngeal cancer and cervical esophageal cancer with that of surgery.
Subjects and Methods: We analyzed 53 cases with advanced hypopharyngeal cancer and 54 cases with advanced cervical esophageal cancer from January, 1995 to December, 2009. Regarding primary treatment, 14 patients with hypopharyngeal cancer and 15 cases with cervical esophageal cancer were classified into a surgery group, and 39 cases with hypopharyngeal cancer and 39 cases with cervical esophageal cancer were classified into a definitive chemoradiotherapy (DCRT) group.
Results: (1)Hypopharyngeal cancer: Five cases in the DCRT group were diagnosed with local recurrence, although there was no local recurrence in the surgery group (
p=0.071). Five-year survival rate was 21.2% in the surgery group compared with 36.6% in the DCRT group. The five-year survival rate of nine cases undergoing salvage surgery in the DCRT group was 22.2%. (2)Cervical esophageal cancer: Five-year survival rate in the surgery group was 53.3%, considerably better than that the 15.6% in the DCRT group.
Conclusion: Surgery for advanced hypopharyngeal cancer tends to more effectively regulate local recurrence than definitive chemoradiotherapy. However, prognosis of DCRT including salvage surgery was similar to that of surgery. In cases with cervical esophageal cancer, prognosis of the Surgery group tended to be better than that in the DCRT group. Therefore, definitive chemoradiotherapy for cervical esophageal cancer should be selected only for patients who wish to preserve the larynx, which had seemed impossible when surgery was the first mode of treatment.
View full abstract